StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Should the Government Allow Same Sex Marriage: Yes - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author gives a brief summary of the situation and discussion of the requisite parts of discussion will help to integrate a more full and complete understanding of the topic as well as a non-emotional approach to an issue that has thus far inflamed emotions on both sides of the political spectrum. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
Should the Government Allow Same Sex Marriage: Yes
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Should the Government Allow Same Sex Marriage: Yes"

The following analysis will approach the issue of gay marriage from the perspective of the arguments both in favor and against the practice. As a means of analyzing these arguments for their logical importance and credibility, the reader will be able to reach an informed decision with regards to whether or not the practice should be allowed as well as supported by the federal government. It is ultimately the hope of the author that the following brief summary of the situation and discussion of the requisite parts of discussion will help to integrate a more full and complete understanding of the topic as well as a non-emotional approach to an issue that has thus far inflamed emotions on both sides of the political spectrum. Outline: Introduction: I: Natural vs “unnatural” marriage A. Discussion of history B. Realization that no firm or solid definition exists C. Marriage as with any other social construct evolves with time II. Prohibition of same-sex marriage from the legal perspective A. Unconstitutional B. Prior precedent notes that denial of rights based upon the definition of marriage is opposed to the framework of the understanding of freedom and of the courts III. Adoption A. Discussion of the thousands of un-adopted children B. Discussion of how well adjusted the children of homosexual couples are C. Discussion of the fact that without legalization these couples cannot adopt IV. Purpose of marriage A. To create babies to provide a loving home for the inhabitants B. Discussion of whether or not would have been if fertility itself were the determinant for being allowed to wed Name Date Professor’s Name Course Section/# Should the Government Allow Same Sex Marriage: Yes! One of the most prominent social questions that exist within the current time is whether or not gay marriage should be legal. The United States is had a very long history of discrimination based upon race, religion, ethnicity, and gender. Unfortunately, even though the United States prides itself on being a free society that offers a range of freedoms to the individuals that choose to live within its borders, the reality is that many of the freedoms that are available to citizens of other countries and regions are not available to individuals within the United States. Accordingly, this brief analysis will seek to discuss some of the main reasons and rationale behind why gay marriage should be legal and fully allowed within each and every one of the states that comprise the union. The importance of the universality of gay marriage within the United States is something that is oftentimes not understood; however, the fact of the matter is that in order for legal gay marriage to mean anything at all, it must be realized within each and every one of the 50 states that comprise the union. This has to do with a litany of factors; not the least of which is with regards to the financial recognition of the institution of marriage that the federal government this does upon the couple. It is the hope of this author that through an analysis of the arguments in support of same-sex marriage, the reader can come to a basic understanding of the logic-based approach that those in favor of same-sex marriage can employ. One of the arguments that many individuals opposed to gay marriage often cites is with regards to the fact that gay marriage is itself unnatural due to the fact that it does not typify a “traditional marriage”. The greatest weakness with regards to this particular point of view is due to the fact that there exists no such definition of the “traditional marriage” that these individuals so often site. Even with regards to anthropology, sociology, or history one can readily find a litany of examples of marriage that were based on polygamy, child brides, arranged marriages, or the use and prevalence of mistresses and concubines. Taken from another perspective, monogamy itself or even choosing to remain unmarried could be termed “unnatural”. As a function of this, the reader can and should realize that there never has been and probably will never be a baseline definition for what constitutes traditional and what constitutes deviant. From the opinion of this author, as long as the individuals involved within the confines of a marriage believe that they intend on spending the rest of their lives together and have a modicum of love and affection, there is no need to deny them of the fundamental human right; as well as the right guaranteed by the Constitution for everyone’s ability to promote their own happiness. While on the topic of the Constitution of the United States, it should be noted that a prohibition on gay marriage is fundamentally unconstitutional. Citing previous court decisions, one can readily point to the US Supreme Court case of Cleveland Board of Education v. LaFleur. The case specifically noted that, freedom a personal choice in matters of marriage and family life is one of the liberties protected by the Due Process Clause”. This case has of course been cited by appeals court judges with reference to ruling the California ban on gay marriage as unconstitutional. However, from the broader perspective, even an individual not familiar with the nuances of the law can determine that restricting and individual’s right to happiness and freedom of choice, where no legal restriction exists, is fundamentally wrong and flawed. The old argument of whether or not growing up with two mothers or two fathers necessarily predisposes one to be homosexual themselves has been fully debunked. Accordingly, it will not be one of the arguments that this author integrates with regards to whether or not gay marriage should be legal in the United States. However, it tangential issue exists. This relates to the fact that each and every year there are approximately 100,000 children waiting to be adopted within the United States alone. Many of these children’s remain within the social care system until they reach 18 years of age (Barry 337). Accordingly, the greater good would ultimately be served by legalizing gay marriage so that an influx of new couples would have the opportunity and desire to adopt many of these on adopted and unloved children. Yet another argument that is often used is that due to the fact that gay couples cannot naturally bring a child into this world that they should therefore not be allowed the privilege of marriage. This is of course an illogical and unreasonable approach and/or determinant to marriage. If one integrates with such an understanding of the meaning of marriage then by extension infertile couples should not be allowed the privilege of marriage either. Looking back upon the fabric and the history of the United States, this would have prevented George and Martha Washington from becoming married as well as a litany of other individuals. Making the creation of children the sole determinant of marriage is both foolish and shortsighted. When approached from a logical perspective, the issue of gay marriage can but be understood from a single perspective. Moreover, due to the fact that the nation itself has a long and dark history of repression, discrimination, and sexism, using tradition and culture to define what marriage should and should not be is ultimately a very weak position to take. Although this brief analysis is only integrated with a handful of arguments in favor of same-sex marriage, the fact of the matter is that a thesis length dissertation could be written on this topic and ultimately, to the same conclusions that this short analysis has revealed. It is the further belief of this author that in much the same way as the civil rights movement, the suffragist movement, and the anti-slavery movement before these contributed to a greater societal understanding of rights and privileges of the disenfranchised, the arguments surrounding same-sex marriage will do very much the same within our own era. Work Cited Barry, Peter Brian. "Same-Sex Marriage And The Charge Of Illiberality." Social Theory & Practice 37.2 (2011): 333-357. Academic Search Complete. Web. 11 Apr. 2013. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Should the Government Allow Same Sex Marriage: Yes Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1473631-should-the-government-allow-same-sex-marriage-yes
(Should the Government Allow Same Sex Marriage: Yes Research Paper)
https://studentshare.org/social-science/1473631-should-the-government-allow-same-sex-marriage-yes.
“Should the Government Allow Same Sex Marriage: Yes Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1473631-should-the-government-allow-same-sex-marriage-yes.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Should the Government Allow Same Sex Marriage: Yes

The Issue Of Same-sex Unions In Modern World

Traditionally and officially, marriage is defined and accepted as the legal union of a man and a woman as husband and wife.... The concept of same-sex marriages simply weakens the definition and respect for the divine institution of marriage.... marriage is not a joke but a life-time commitment and same-sex marriages fail to last longer.... It is an unnatural concept and unless a great deal of effort is not put in, it's hard to maintain or stabilize marriage by gay couples....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Same-Sex Marriages Should Be Legally Recognized

society has become much more tolerant towards people who prefer partners of the same sex as theirs, but still those people experience numerous problems with the state legal system.... Eric Stoltz, the author of the article about Proposition 22, a law project that banned recognition of the same sex marriages in California, writes:I could, for example, fly to Las Vegas tonight, wed a prostitute in a drunken stupor, and return to Los Angeles tomorrow morning to have my marriage fully recognized by the law and society....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Methods on muslim arrange marriages

Arranged marriages could possibly be a better institution of marriage because it creates stability of families and therefore better protection of children.... This study looks into arranged marriages, that has happened in all cultures throughout the centuries.... In the twentieth century, this institution became an icon of the past in the west, because of the women's rights movement the freeing of sexuality....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Gay Marriage

same sex marriage is a right; just as heterosexual couples have the right to celebrate their union so do gay and lesbian people.... same sex marriage does not threaten the institution of marriage; if the real definition of marriage is the union between a man and a woman to procreate than why several heterosexual couples are choosing careers ahead of having children.... same sex marriage is a lie; a deception man has coined to satisfy his/her gratifications....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

The Marriage (Same Sex Couples)

Same-sex marriage (also known as gay marriage) is marriage between two persons of the same sex sex/gender.... Legal recognition of same-sex marriage or the likelihood to perform a same-sex marriage is some of the time alluded to as marriage equality or equivalent marriage, especially by supporters.... The primary laws in modern times, empowering same-sex marriage were established amid the first decade of the 21st century.... Uruguay and New Zealand have both sanctioned laws to legitimize same-sex marriage, which has come into energy in August 2013....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

The Institution of Marriage and Family

The paper 'The Institution of Marriage and Family' touches upon the institution of marriage and family which is threatened by same-sex marriage.... This is because traditionally, marriage is between a man and a woman and since marriage is ordained by God and has so been since the beginning.... hellip; In addition to this, marriage is the self-sacrificing and complimentary lifestyle that places the interest of one another and children first and is a true creation legacy....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

The Debate over Same-Sex Marriages

The paper contains an argumentative essay about same-sex marriage.... The arguments favoring marriage invoke the basic right of equality for every individual while the opposing school of thought debates that same-sex marriage will destroy the basis of our culture and society.... Apart from these states, there are 10 states in the United States which allow same-sex unions and partnerships.... The author states that marriage is based on a love of the partners which is equally the same in same-sex and heterosexual marriages....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Letter to the U.S Government Concerning Gay Marriage Concerns

We as the makers of the government need your support to assist them in celebrating the responsibilities brought from marriages (Gay, 48).... the government must realize that this is not a state issue but a federal matter constitutional right.... I would urge the government to provide an exceedingly strong reason if it would want to stop this right.... Government Concerning Gay marriage Concerns” states that two individuals of similar sex and bound by love ought to be allowed to openly celebrate their relationship commitments and also access similar benefits as the heterosexual married couples....
5 Pages (1250 words) Personal Statement
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us