StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Merchant of Venice Antonio's trial (Act 4) - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Shylock, when asked why he would only be satisfied with the flesh of Antonio instead of the money that he lent, argues that it might indeed be strange to the others, but there are people who do and feel strange things without any cause, so his requirement for the flesh of…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful
The Merchant of Venice Antonios trial (Act 4)
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Merchant of Venice Antonio's trial (Act 4)"

Write a summary of the points of argument presented by both sides (Antonio and Shylock). Shylock, when asked why he would only be satisfied with theflesh of Antonio instead of the money that he lent, argues that it might indeed be strange to the others, but there are people who do and feel strange things without any cause, so his requirement for the flesh of Antonio can be listed as just one of those inexplicable things that cannot be answered. He also states that to deny him this right would cause the city to fall into disrepute for denying justice.

Antonio simply states that to expect Shylock to show mercy is next to impossible. He states a few impossible tasks like asking the tides not to rise, expecting the wolf to show pity to the ewe and not to devour the lamb, and to expect the firs not to make noise when the wind blows throw them, and then goes on to say that these are easily done as compared to expecting Shylock to be merciful.Shylock answers to the accusation by stating that he is no less merciless than the rest of the so called civilized men present there.

He states how these people mistreat their slaves and how none of them would dream of treating them on equal footing with themselves. He then asks why it is that he is expected to forego his “pound of flesh” when they do not forfeit their slaves.Analyze the factores of argument used and identify these with those that both Shylock used & the lawyer (Portia) used. Consider the key factors as presented in your text book (Beyond feelings by Vicent Ryab Ruggiero 8th edition) - both the positive & negative forms of argument.

Shylock uses negative arguments to state why it is that he would not give up his right to take Antonio’s flesh. He uses affirmative argument as to why the bond must be carried out to the letter. The arguments that Antonio uses to state why it is useless to expect mercy from Shylock are negative. It is easy to see how he builds the premise to prove that Shylock is heard-hearted. The stated premise here is that impossible things can be achieved more easily than to get Shylock to change his heart.

The Conclusion being that Shylock will not change his mind, for he is merciless.When Portia and Shylock argue later on, Portia first of all uses affirmative argument towards showing mercy, which Shylock simply denies by using the negative argument, which is that the law allows him to get the bond enforced, so there is no need for mercy.Portia uses affirmative arguments, whereas Antonio shows negative arguments towards a show of mercy. Portia states why Shylock should be merciful whereas Antonio avers how Shylock would not be merciful.

Shylock’s own arguments remain the same, whether he is arguing with Portia or with Antonio. His premise is simple that as he is not required to show mercy under any law, therefore, he will not do so.Conclude with the affect these arguments had on you which were most/least persuasive to you.The least persuasive argument for me was the one put forward by Shylock as to what reasons he had for asking for Antonio’s flesh. The argument he gave was that just like some people hate things without knowing why, or are scared of something without knowing the reason, therefore, he should not be asked to assign a reason as to why he wanted Antonio’s flesh.

It was very illogical as if the argument given by Shylock is followed, it can be clearly observed that the feelings that the people have in such cases are not voluntary on their part; it is involuntary on the part of a man to be so scared of a cat, whereas what Shylock is doing is voluntary and he has full control over his actions.On another note, when stating why he will not show mercy, the arguments that Shylock makes are very persuasive. The way he propounds how those who call themselves merciful are actually merciless themselves is very beautifully done.

He does not mention their lack of mercy, he simply states that they treat their slaves as their animals and that they will never give their slaves the same place as other humans, and then asks why should he forego his right to a pound of flesh in such a case. The hidden premise here being that when others are not willing to let go of the whole body of a man (their slave) then why are they shocked when he will not let go of his right over a pound of flesh of another man.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Merchant of Venice Antonio's trial (Act 4) Essay”, n.d.)
The Merchant of Venice Antonio's trial (Act 4) Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1543354-the-merchant-of-venice-antonios-trial-act-4
(The Merchant of Venice Antonio'S Trial (Act 4) Essay)
The Merchant of Venice Antonio'S Trial (Act 4) Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1543354-the-merchant-of-venice-antonios-trial-act-4.
“The Merchant of Venice Antonio'S Trial (Act 4) Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1543354-the-merchant-of-venice-antonios-trial-act-4.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Merchant of Venice Antonio's trial (Act 4)

The Merchant of Venice

As seen through the lens of Marxist criticism, the merchant of venice presents a conflict that relates to the issues of money and power.... Therefore, basing on Marxist criticism, this analysis endeavors to scrutinize William Shakespeare's romantic comedy, the merchant of venice through a thematic approach of the class antagonism evident in the play.... In the merchant of venice, the theme develops around the manipulative potentials of the characters towards wealth in order maintain social equality....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Different Interpretations of the Relationship between Antonio and Bassanio

Name Instructor Date Different Interpretations of the Relationship between Antonio and Bassanio in the merchant of venice The ‘Merchant of Venice' by William Shakespeare has been a subject of intensive analysis and diverse interpretations.... From one act to another, scene-to-scene Bassanio is seen to be concerned about the welfare of Antonio and vice versa.... In demonstration of how tight they are in their relationship, Antonio goes ahead to act as a guarantor for the money that Bassanio borrows from Shylock, a moneylender....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Merchant of Venice and anti-Semitism in the Treatment of Shylock

Shakespeare wrote the merchant of venice at a time when few Jews lived in England, from where they had been forcibly expelled in 1290 by Edward I.... (Oldrieve, 87) Next to Hamlet, the merchant of venice is Shakespeare's most frequently performed play.... Glock, 144-50) Shylock, of course, is not the only important character in the merchant of venice, which takes its title from Antonio, the Venetian merchant who borrows from Shylock to help his friend, Bassanio....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Anti-Semitism in Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice

The character of Shylock in Shakespeare's the merchant of venice (c.... Also referred to as The Jew of venice, Shakespeare's play has similarities with Marlowe's The Jew of Malta (c.... In act II, scene viii, Solanio fuses two of these relationships to create comic effect: the bond between parent and child, and the connection between creditor and debtor....
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review

The Merchant of Venice by William Shakespeare

the merchant of venice, the celebrated romantic comedy by William Shakespeare, has been one of the most renowned plays by the author and it deals with various themes including the relationship between love and money.... Set in Venice, Italy during the Renaissance, the merchant of venice deals mainly with about the love exploits of several Italian characters.... As the title page of the Quarto text indicates, the play mainly focuses on three important plot lines: first, Antonio the merchant of venice; second, Shylock, the rapacious Jewish money-lender; and third, the courting and winning of Portia, a singularly wealthy young heiress....
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review

Merchant Of Venice by Shakespeare

There are many fairytale elements in 'the merchant f Venice'.... Although 'the merchant f Venice' displays a few characteristics from fairytales, there are very obvious elements missing such as magic and a moral to all that has happened.... (Buckley 20-22) The main characteristic that 'the merchant f Venice' contains is that f the number three being used throughout the duration f the play.... There are a lot f examples f '"three" in the merchant f Venice, similar to that f the aforementioned fairytale....
11 Pages (2750 words) Book Report/Review

Why Shakespeare Used Religious Themes in His Plays

There are many biblical connotations in almost all of Shakespeare's plays, but one of the most appealing uses of biblical references can be seen in Shakespeare's play, the merchant of venice.... The relationship between the Christian and the Jew is of vital importance in the play and it demonstrates a trial of the two people thus having religious connotations....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Summaries of Each Scene Acts I-V of the Merchant of Venice by William Shakespeare

The paper contains the summaries of each scene Acts I-V of the "merchant of venice" by William Shakespeare.... The author describes how Antonio appears in court with the Duke of venice, who is clearly in sympathy with Antonio and tries to convince Shylock that he is only trying to frighten Antonio.... In the end, the Duke mercifully allows Shylock to keep his half of the estate by only charging Shylock a fine and Antonio also allows Shylock to keep antonio's half of the estate if he will agree to convert to Christianity and will all of his holdings to Lorenzo and Jessica upon his death....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us