StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Jury Selection and Psychology of the American Jury - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Jury Selection and Psychology of the American Jury" discusses the tough issues of jury trials such as the use of surveys in jury selection, in-court approaches to jury selection, voir dire procedures, persuasion in the courtroom, focus groups, trial simulations, and shadow juries…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Jury Selection and Psychology of the American Jury
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Jury Selection and Psychology of the American Jury"

 

  1. Kressel, N. and Dorit F. Kressel (2004). "Stack and Sway: The New Science of Jury Consulting" by. Journal of Forensic Psychology Practice 4.2 (2004

            Written by Neil Kressel, a social psychologist at New Jersey's William Paterson University, and his wife Dorit, a practicing attorney, this book provides an even-handed accounting of the methods and ethical issues of the phenomenon called jury consultancy and its possible implications for American justice. It provides a discussion regarding the use of jury consultants in sensitive matters such as race and answers the question What do jury consultants do? Are their elaborate efforts to assist lawyers in the jury selection process by identifying attitudes, values, and would-be demographic predictors merely benign efforts to screen for biases that could jeopardize fair trials, as practitioners like to claim?

  1. Golden, Charles (2007). “Can Scientific Jury Selection Produce Fair juries, or Just Juries With a Different Bias?” in PsycCritiques, Vol 52 (6), 2007. US American Psychological Association.

            Scientific Jury Selection is a well-written volume that reviews the research and issues surrounding scientific jury selection. The authors examine the many factors and methods involved in this process and provide a balanced and comprehensive review of the literature as well as raise important scientific and ethical questions. Chapters review such factors as methods of acquiring information and applying those methods to the actual process of jury selection. The volume raises substantial issues about the accuracy and efficacy of the selection process, as well as its ethical and legal implications. In addition, it provides the basis for the psychological methods used.

  1. A. Austin (1984). Complex Litigation Confronts the Jury System, 103-104. Greenwood Press, US.

            Austin provides a case study in which one could gain valuable insight into the workings of jury consultancy and provides analysis and possible implications of the methods used thru the case study presented.

  1. Leci, L., Snowden, J. and Morris, D (2004). "Using Social Science Research to Inform and Evaluate the Contributions of Trial Consultants in the Voir Dire." Journal of Forensic Psychology Practice 4.2 (2004) 67-78

            The authors argue that the jury selection methods commonly employed by trial consultants and lawyers in the voir dire process are fraught with problems because they do not employ standardized assessments. This commentary provides and advocates the advantages of employing standardized, reliable, and validated measures of pretrial juror bias to conduct the voir dire, and we delineate some of the methods by which this can be accomplished.

  1. Lieberman, Joel D., and Bruce D. Sales (2007). “Overall Effectiveness of Scientific Jury Selection” in PsycINFO. Washington DC, US: American Psychological Association, 2007.

            Lieberman and Sales provide discussion on matters of jury consultancy such as the Purpose and effectiveness of the Voir Dire, the influence of demographic factors, the influence of Personality and Attitudes, in-court questioning of prospective jurors, and ethical and professional issues in Scientific Jury Selection. 

  1. Van Wallendael, Lori, and Brian Cutler (2004). "Limitations to Empirical Approaches to Jury Selection" in Journal of Forensic Psychology Practice 4.2 (2004): 79-86.

            This composition questions the superiority of social scientific approaches to voir dire on two grounds. First, the advantage of social scientific methods over normative approaches has not been established. Thus, we have little empirical understanding of normative approaches to voir dire and therefore have little basis for comparison. Second, the variability in voir dire procedure from the courtroom to courtroom and the lack of empirical knowledge on how this variability in practice affects traditional or social scientific approaches to voir dire makes generalizations premature.

  1. Suggs, David, U Nebraska, Lincoln Sales, Bruce D. (1978). "The art and science of conducting the voir dire." in Professional Psychology, Vol 9 (3) Aug 1978. pp. 367-388.          

            In this article, the techniques in voir dire are discussed and one can see the methods used and provide an evaluation of the ethical issues surrounding jury consultancy.
 

  1. Jeffrey T. Frederick, Ph.D. (1984). “Social Science Involvement in the Voir Dire: Preliminary Data on the effectiveness of Scientific jury Selection"  in Behavioral Sciences & The Law Vol. 2 No. 4 1984

            Dr. Frederick argues on whether scientific or systematic jury selection is more effective and takes data from two actual cases one of which is the Joan Little trial and argues that where validity data were available for the survey approach and in-court rating of authoritarianism, these techniques measured what they purported to measure. Validation data were not available for a third technique - in-court rating of nonverbal communication. Data from the civil case indicated that the survey approach could successfully predict the verdicts of mock jurors.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Jury Selection Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Jury Selection Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1515240-jury-selection
(Jury Selection Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Jury Selection Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1515240-jury-selection.
“Jury Selection Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1515240-jury-selection.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Jury Selection and Psychology of the American Jury

History of Forensic Psychology

Forensic psychology deals with courtroom issues like jury selection and with the evaluation of evidence.... Forensic psychology is a field of study linked to both the criminal justice system and psychology.... The paper 'History of Forensic psychology" focuses on the critical analysis and discussing the history of forensic psychology in great detail to understand how it has evolved over the years.... It aims to understand how forensic psychology has flourished into what it is today....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Psychologists and Jury Selection

To start with, the american legal system is unique for its use of scientific jury selection.... Scientific jury selection involves the specific use of specific social science techniques in order to get the best favorable jurists for a particular trial.... According to the research findings, it can, therefore, be said that it is widely accepted that scientific jury selection is largely effective.... It is very difficult even to keep the jury selection procedure just as it would involve discrimination against minority religions, races, nationalities and other cognizable groups....
3 Pages (750 words) Term Paper

Loophole in the Legal System

a) Numerous high-profile trials have been witnessed in which controversial verdicts were attributed to race - the race of the defendant, the racial composition of a jury, an attorney "playing the race card," etc.... a predominantly Black jury's acquittal of O.... In the wake of theses trials, many have questioned the viability of the United States' jury system (Kapardis, 1997; Reynolds, 1996).... a) Numerous high-profile trials have been witnessed in which controversial verdicts were attributed to race - the race of the defendant, the racialcomposition of a jury, an attorney "playing the race card," etc....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Jury Selection Process

"Scientific jury selection" paper provides some of the key points of the issue of clouding the practice of jury consultancy.... Evidence from academia largely indicates that scientific jury selection does no good, yet the market for such services continues to flourish.... hat methods do jury selection experts employ What are the bases for the controversy surrounding this "hot" field What, if any, solutions have been suggested to alleviate these concerns In jury selection, social scientists gain prominence but jury consultancy remains controversial in both the legal and social scientific communities (Stolle, Robbenolt & Wiener, 1996)?...
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Psychology to Understanding of the Judge and Jury Decisions

This essay "Psychology to Understanding of the Judge and jury Decisions" focuses on details of psychology in the courtroom and in other aspects of the criminal and civil justice system.... IntroductionIn the recent past, psychology has been applied in numerous ways inside the courtroom.... However, there are instances where psychology may not be appropriate.... psychology and the criminal justice system are quite different.... The criminal justice system aims at giving punishment to wrongdoers while the field of psychology mostly focuses on the reasons behind the offender's actions....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

The Concept of a Trial by a Jury

It was during the time of Penn's trial that the american jury system began to establish itself as a protective barrier between the government and the accused man.... odern jury selection techniques in America today ensure that both sides are well represented by the jury panel.... This paper "The Concept of a Trial by a jury" focuses on the notion which takes its roots from the British Magna Carta 1215.... This concept provides the present day practice where an ideal jury panel is representative of the defendant's peers with no special requirements....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Selection of Juries and Trial Consultants

In the essay 'The Selection of Juries and Trial Consultants' the author claims that civil trial attorneys about to begin a jury selection process without using 'an empirical-based approach' through the use of psychologists or jury consultants it is almost malpractice if the case is a large one.... The author emphasizes the importance many attorneys places on the advancements in jury selection when comparing it to their own speculation and intuitiveness.... Scientific jury selection improves the outcome of the trial depending on the type of case according to research conducted by Seltzer (2006)....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Jury Selection Process

he jury selection procedure for the case took two The jury selection was interesting in the sense that it had 9 blacks, 1 Hispanic and 2 Whites in it, a total of 12 jury participants – 10 women and 2 men.... Simpson was tried at the Chicago court against a panel of jury in the most highly publicized court hearing in American history.... he jury sequestration is a highly complicated matter and requires considerable attention of the selecting bodies....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us