StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

English Legal Systems and Skills - Report Example

Cite this document
Summary
This report "English Legal Systems and Skills" focuses on the case that was an allegation that the claimant had sexually assaulted a fifteen-year-old schoolboy who was undergoing a short period of work experience at the school where the claimant had been newly employed as music assistance. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.4% of users find it useful
English Legal Systems and Skills
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "English Legal Systems and Skills"

English Legal Systems and Skills of English Legal Systems and Skills Material facts of the case and initial grounds of appeal The case was an allegation that the claimant had sexually assaulted a fifteen year old school boy who was undergoing a short period of work experience at the school where the claimant had been newly employed as music assistance. It was alleged that the claimant had inappropriate contact with the boy and further that inappropriate text from the claimant to the boy inviting the boy to meet him were found in the boy’s phone. The school consequently expelled the claimant from working in the school. The initial grounds of appeal by the appellant was that he was denied his right to legal representation1 by the school board which amounted to gross violation of his rights under the European Convention on human Rights that among other rights provide for a right to a legal representation2. Legal issues upon which G’s case was heard at first instance The legal issue to be proved at first instance was whether there was any form of sexual contact between the claimant and the boy. They had to establish whether there was any form of improper contact that would attract disciplinary action against the claimant. On founding of a disciplinary action, a report would be forwarded to the Secretary of State to consider any future employment of the claimant especially in any employment position that would put him in any kind of contact with school going children. The panel should consider whether the actions constitute an abuse of trust of his implicit position in the school and consequently constituting gross misconduct. Legal issues identified in the appeal in the Supreme Court One of the legal issues that were identified by the Supreme Court was whether the claimant’s rights had been violated at the hearing in the first instance. It has to consider whether the denial of the claimant’s legal representation amounted to a violation of his rights. The claimant had been denied representation by his counsel in the hearings at the tribunal. In fact the tribunal went ahead to make a decision having denied her this right. In any case involving the determination of a person’s civil rights as well as obligations of any criminal charge against him, he is entitled to a public and fair hearing that should be conducted within a reasonable time by an impartial and independent tribunal that has been established by law. Another principle issue for determination is the question on determining the kind of connection that is required to exist between the proceedings in A that do not determine civil rights and obligation and proceedings B which determined civil rights and obligation. The court has to determine whether the connection is strong enough to determine the proceeding’s outcome. Another issue for determination was whether the proceeding by ISA which went ahead to include his name in the children barred list would violate his rights under article 6 (1). Another issue for the Supreme Court to determine was what statutory regulation to apply. Regulation 4 of 2003 regulations could not apply in a case where the secretary had not invited representations by 20th January 2009. The Ratio ‘decidendi’ in the case An appeal can be made to the Supreme Court only on the grounds that the ISA has erred on a point of law or erred in a finding of a fact that it has made and the decision was based on that finding of fact. The decision on whether it was in order for an individual to be included in a barred list is not a question of law or fact as per section 4(3). The court decided this case based on the decision in Austrian case3 that held that it must be shown that the dispute relates to civil rights and obligations. Relevance of Article 6 (1) of the European Convention to this case This Article safeguards a person’s right to a fair trial. The article in criminal cases as well as in civil cases safeguards the right to a hearing that should be conducted in public as well as by an independent and impartial tribunal. It further holds that such trial should be conducted within a reasonable time as well as the presumption of innocence where one is presumed innocent until they are proved guilty4. Finally the Article provides rights for those charged with offences to be accorded with enough time to prepare for their defense, be allowed to access legal representation be allowed to examine witness and if they don’t understand the language of the court they be provided with an interpreter. This article is relevant in this case because one of the issues as well as one of the grounds for appeal was the allegation by the claimant that their rights had been violated. The claimant alleges that he was denied the right to be represented by an advocate in the proceedings in the tribunal. The significance of the case of Ringeisin v Australia in this case The issue in this case involved refusal by the Austrian District and regional property to effect approval of some plots of land. The person who was seeking the approval was challenging the refusal alleging that the refusal was biased and violated his rights under Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Since the approval was refused any sale purportedly effected without the approval was null and void and of no effect whatsoever. The court held in this case that when the applicant purchased the property, there was a right to have the contract approved by the council. The court could proceed on this basis to decide if the proceedings in the present case complied with what was laid down in Article Six of the convention. It is therefore evident that the case is relevant in this case because it provides the guideline for courts to consider in deciding whether a person’s rights have been violated as provided for under Article six of the European Convention on Human Rights. The case in point involves a determination of the issue as to whether the claimant rights as provided by the convention have been violated. Dissenting judgment A dissenting opinion is an opinion that does not agree with the majority due to a number of reasons. This could be as a result of differing interpretation of the case law, using different principles in a particular situation or also applying the existing facts in a particular situation differently. A dissenting opinion usually is not a binding precedent and doesn’t form case law5. However, dissents can be used to form persuasive authorities especially in contending that a court’s ruling needs to be overturned. A persuasive authority is one that can be used to influence the court in its decision but that which the court is not bound to follow. In other instances a dissent that occurred in an earlier case can be applied to cause a change law that is later used by a majority in writing a later decision based on the dissent6. There is a dissenting judgment in the instant case. It is dissenting in the sense that while majority of the judges allow the appeal one judge doesn’t allow it and contends that the appeal should be dismissed. The dissenting opinion is by Lord Brown. He doesn’t agree with other judges reasons for allowing the appeal. The majority decision allowing the appeal is by the four other judges. In his dissenting opinion, he disagrees with the majority holding that all requirements of by Article six of the convention should be present in all hearings. He asserts an impartial tribunal requirement can be considered at a later stage of the hearing by the tribunal. In this case it is not in order to consider the question as to whether the court considered Article six. Effect of the European Court Judgment on the UK Supreme Court The Supreme Court is the highest decision making court in the United Kingdom. The United Kingdom has discretion on whether or not to apply the decisions made by the European Court in determining cases before it7. But whenever the Supreme Court is applying the convention, it is bound to apply the European court jurisprudence. The European Union convention has in very many cases influenced the decisions made by the UK Supreme Court. The effect of the European court judgments can therefore be binding or not binding to the Supreme Court. It depends on the judge before which a particular case is being heard. In case where a European Court has made a decisions concerning a particular case, such a decision can in instances where it is not binding be used as a persuasive authority before the Supreme Court8. However, the decision on whether or not to follow European Courts decisions depends on the circumstances of a particular case9. If it is a matter alleging the violation of European Union law, the court must have regard to the law of the European Union that is applicable in particular circumstances10. The court in interpreting the domestic law it is not bound at all to follow European Court decision11. The Supreme Court should refer to the European Court of Justice (ECJ) that is based in Luxembourg all questions pertaining to European Union law12. Whenever the Court is giving effect to all the rights in the European Convention on Human Rights, it should take into consideration all decisions made by the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg13. No court is allowed to dilute or alter the decisions that have been delivered by the European Court14. Any person whose rights have been violated by any court can bring a claim against the violation to the European Court on Human Rights15. Bibliography 1. Kurkan v Milton Keynes Hospital NHS Trust (2009) 2. Article 6(1) of the European Convention on Human Right 3. Ringesein v Austria no. 1 1971 ECHR 455 4. R (Wright) v Secretary of State for Health [2009] 1 AC 739 5. Journal of Supreme Court History. Volume 19, Issue 1, pages 33–44, December 1994 6. Deumeland v Germany (1986) 8 EHRR 448 7. Sueur, P. A. (2004). Building the UKs new Supreme Court: National and comparative perspectives. Oxford University Press 8. “Justice of the UK Supreme Court." London, United Kingdom 9. Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (article 267) 10. Lord Bingham of Cornhill in R (Ullah) v Special Adjudicator [2004] UKHL 26 11. The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom: History, Art, Architecture Chris Miele ed. (Merrell) 12. Official Journal of the European Union 13. Human Right Act 1988 14. Administration of Justice Act 1997 15. Constitutional Reform Act 2005 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(English Legal Systems and Skills Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words - 1, n.d.)
English Legal Systems and Skills Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words - 1. https://studentshare.org/law/1762262-english-legal-system-skills
(English Legal Systems and Skills Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words - 1)
English Legal Systems and Skills Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words - 1. https://studentshare.org/law/1762262-english-legal-system-skills.
“English Legal Systems and Skills Report Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words - 1”. https://studentshare.org/law/1762262-english-legal-system-skills.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF English Legal Systems and Skills

Statement of purpose

Furthermore, with the ASEAN Community expected to come into effect in 2015, Thai lawyers need to learn how to deal with the different legal systems among those countries.... In this regard, I also believe this program will help me pave the way for understanding and analyzing the diversity of the legal systems among the ASEAN group, especially the countries adopting the common law system, such as Malaysia, Singapore, and Brunei.... Moreover my experience at SMU really improved my English language skills both in speaking and writing along with familiarizing me the American educational system....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Is the Current State of the Law Satisfactory in the Way It Deals With the Right to Claim in Tort

Moreover, although, the parameters detailed in the formation of a valid Contract are reasonably wide the restrictions obliged within a legal system on liability in Tort (limitation of claims in time and narrowly defined vicarious liability) may not permit the fair treatment of claims emanating out of direct dealings between the parties within circumstances in which a valid contract cannot be interfered (Wright 23).... The english Law seeks the means to limit liability in Negligence in which, under the initial design of this tort would only hinge on proof of foreseeable harm....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Business and Accounting

For me, learning is not only a process of gaining knowledge, values and skills through formal study but from experiences in working as well.... To develop knowledge and skills required in this world, I therefore believe that studying the Business and Economic program offered in the University of California would prepare me to become a successful businessman.... Even by just being a receptionist, I learned that it takes a lot of diverse skills such as good communications and sensitivity of other's needs is needed to do a good job in any business....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The English Legal System

The english legal advocacy system was first split into Solicitors and Barristers in the nineteenth century, when the Bar agreed to concede the administrative aspects of the profession as embodied in conveyancing and direct client access to the solicitors.... Since these legal professionals charge by the hour and costs are particularly high for Queens Counsels who are allowed audience in the High Court and Crown Courts, this has often pushed the option of litigation right out if the province of poorer clients....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Community Sentencing

Nations which lack community sentencing in their legal systems have also expressed that such programs would be a valuable addition to their courts (121st International Training Course, n.... Those people who commit less violent crimes and are liable to receive a short term prison sentence should instead be allowed to engage in rehabilitation programs which would help them learn specific skills.... All the programs are designed to make the offenders accountable for their crimes and at the same time help them to develop new job skills (Anderson, 1998)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

My Personal Development Portfolio

For one thing, the legal system here operates with a higher degree of fairness, and the freedom of speech, too, is something, I admit, I had never experienced before.... … I adopted such a mindset early on, thanks to my family which consistently exposed me to the new world order, such as the english language and Western values.... Russian being my primary language, I have no shame whatsoever admitting that learning the english language was rather difficult at first, though I'd like to think I have now been able to attain a certain degree of proficiency in it....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Social Problem in America Immigration

Due to the diversity of education, Majority of immigrant possesses skills and expertise that are threatening to the American citizens.... Education is the solution to a successful life for the illegal immigrants as well as the legal citizens of America.... Essentially, in most cases, legal citizens use the services of the illegal immigrants to carry out criminal activities in the country as they cannot be identified easily (Panayi 211).... The government needs to have reforms that will address the venerable problems of illegal immigrants as wells legal immigrants....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Legal System and Skills

The appeal was referred by CCRC on the basis that the decision in Morgan Smith had changed the legal position.... Having had an unhappy marriage, this couple had separated on December 1978.... Mrs.... James then left their matrimonial home where she formed another relationship with Nigel Dutfield....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us