StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Legal Standings of Journalist Reports - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper "Legal Standings of Journalist Reports" focuses on the fact that the court at Sunderland Youth Court had a dramatic time hearing the case of young-love-gone-sour. The morning of Monday saw the court preside over one of the most bizarre cases in Sunderland for the past decade. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.5% of users find it useful
Legal Standings of Journalist Reports
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Legal Standings of Journalist Reports"

? COURT REPORT By Court Report Case The court at Sunderland Youth Court on Monday morning had a dramatic time hearing the case of young-love-gone-sour. The morning of Monday saw the court preside over one of the most bizarre cases in Sunderland for the past decade. A school boy aged 14 years was charged in the court for murdering his 14 year old girlfriend. The inopportune incident was reported to have occurred on December 4 2013. Both teenagers were students studying for their GCSE examinations in a Withington Academy. While presenting the case, the prosecution reiterated that the girl had been found murdered in a field near Seaburn Metro Station over the weekend. She had five stubs in the stomach and medical reports presented in the court showed that she died from shock and internal bleeding. Before the body was discovered, the 14 year old girl had gone missing since Friday when she failed to return from school. A dog walker discovered the body of the girl lifeless in the field the following morning as police was already conducting a search. According to witnesses, the accused boy had squabbles with the dead girlfriend days before the incident. Detectives are still awaiting the test results of DNA samples collected from a knife used in the murder. The defendant’s lawyer, Doug Richardson asked the court to bail him out, citing the defendant had no previous criminal records. The court denied request for the bail given the weight of a murder charge. The defendant remains in police custody awaiting the next court hearing as the victim awaits burial next month. Commentary Whereas journalists have the responsibility to provide the community with accurate information of the happenings going on around them, there are legal responsibilities they have to consider when reporting events (Banks 2012, 02). Court proceedings are sensitive. While reporting the murder case involving the teenager, Paul Ross, the law requires that the name of the defendant be withheld. Whereas there is never any problem mentioning the name of the victim unless in a sexual assault or rape case, I chose to withhold the name of Monica Smith to protect identity of the accused. Additionally, the report does not detail the names of the parents of the accused and the victim for the same reason of protection of identity. This is particularly imperative given the fact that a defendant remains innocent until proved guilty in a legal procedure. In addition, the report fails to mention remarks reported in the court as having transpired before and after the incident. Before the murder, the defendant is reported to have states, “If I can’t have her, no one can.” Additionally, Ross is recorded to have broken down and confessed killing his girlfriend during police interrogation. He said, “I didn’t mean to kill her, just frighten her with the knife.” This report dodges these comments primarily to prevent a scenario that may show prejudice and bias. The journalist report fails to mention these statements as that would seem as though the journalist already has a formed opinion that Ross is guilty. It leaves the legal responsibility of determining innocence or guilt to the judiciary. Second Court Case The Newcastle Magistrates Court on Monday bailed out a revered Newcastle barrister after an awry “blind date” led to a lawsuit. The 33-year-old resident was charged with attempted rape of 19 year old Sunderland University Law student. The two were strangers to each other until Friday night when they met at a popular nightclub in town. The young woman claimed that they did not know each other until that evening when the defendant bought her drinks and asked her out to smoke cigarette. She says it was at that moment that the defendant tries raping her, raised an alarm and escaped before calling the police. In his defense, the 33-year old Newcastle resident reiterated that they had mutual consent to spend the night in a hotel room next to the nightclub. He said he simply tried to kiss her, but the mistress raised alarm citing sexual assault. The married man of three children said his marriage was going through severe problems, and this led him to the act that he regretted. As he applied for a bailing, the defendant’s solicitor, John London appealed that he be released on bail given his good character. The solicitor argued that the defendant had an outstanding reputation in the society and character-wise and deserved to be set free on a cash bail. The court released him on bail, but imposed an 8pm to 8am curfew upon him until another hearing next Monday at Newcastle Crown Courts. Commentary Like in the previous case, there are legal responsibilities journalists have to consider when reporting events. Court proceedings are sensitive. Considering the nature of the case; sexual assault case, the scenarios surrounding the case are discomfiting and embarrassing. This calls for the need to uphold a great sense of confidentiality and privacy in reporting the case (Ustundag 2013, 30). Both the defendant and the victim in this particular court proceeding have the right to be protected from undue publicity. For this reason, it is necessary to conceal the identity of Peter Michaels and Ms Jill Parsons. Including the ages of the two awakens the readers’ imagination and allows them to get a picture of the situation as it was in the courtroom and the scene of alleged crime. Legally, it is wrong to expose identity of the family of one suspected for committing crime (Myerson 2013, 32). This is the reason why the names of the family members of Michaels are missing in the media report. The law provides that journalists conceal the names of loved ones of the defendant to protect them from public humiliation, intimidation and embarrassment. Respect and safety of his wife Jemima and their children Sam, eight, and Lorna, two are, therefore, protected. Further, the report does not mention that Michaels is a respected barrister who defends criminal cases at Newcastle and Durham Crown Courts to protect his image. However, facts mentioned in the police interviews about his family problems are mentioned discriminately to allow the readers get the true picture of the case. It prevents one from demonizing the defendant, an occurrence that can potentially cause public unrest of University of Sunderland students if the court might find Michaels innocent and acquaint him. Bibliography MYERSON, J. M. (2013). Legal Standings of Journalist Reports. Boca Raton [u.a.], Auerbach Publ./Taylor & Francis. BANKS, J. (2012). Journalism and the Law of Privacy applied. Hoboken, NJ, Wiley. USTUNDAG, A. (2013). The value of Responsible Reporting benefits vs. costs. London, Springer. http://allaboutinformation.ca/2008/03/18/case-report-oca-sets-aside-contempt-order-issued-against-journalist/ Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Legal Standings of Journalist Reports Assignment, n.d.)
Legal Standings of Journalist Reports Assignment. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1496837-court-reporting-write-up-two-court-reports-from
(Legal Standings of Journalist Reports Assignment)
Legal Standings of Journalist Reports Assignment. https://studentshare.org/law/1496837-court-reporting-write-up-two-court-reports-from.
“Legal Standings of Journalist Reports Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1496837-court-reporting-write-up-two-court-reports-from.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Legal Standings of Journalist Reports

Carl Hiaasens Florida in Fiction and in Reality

A journalist is in a better position to see the squalid reality of life.... His experience of Florida is not the second hand experience of a touring journalist.... But his career as a journalist has given him the opportunity to travel and hence in his assessment of his homeland there is the comparative advantage of the itinerant journalist who captures the images of other places to look at his own place in a proper comparative perspective....
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review

Poems of Tevfik Fikret and Mehmet Akif Ersoy

Evocations f Utopia are as time-honored as Turkish culture.... As nomads in Central Asia (before their exodus into Asia Minor started in the ninth century), Turks had already given eloquent expression to their yearning for heavenly havens.... Having embraced Islam in the succeeding centuries, they became enamored f the Koran's irresistible descriptions f paradise....
10 Pages (2500 words) Book Report/Review

The 1972 Presidential Election

Crouse was then a young reporter for the music magazine Rolling Stones who tagged along with veteran journalist Hunter S.... The author of the paper 'The 1972 Presidential Election' focuses on Timothy Crouse's book “The Boys on the Bus” which published in 1973.... Thompson....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review

Kinds of Crisis Situation and the Consequences

The author of the current paper states that 7-Eleven is an international chain of company-owned or franchised convenience stores, which is owned by Japan's Seven & I Holdings Co.... It cannot be smooth sailing all the time for 7-Eleven, as they could face various problems or importantly crisis....
7 Pages (1750 words) Lab Report

Foundations of Global Business

This discussion talks that the trend in the newspaper industry is changing in the developed countries, where the demand for a print newspaper is being replaced with a much higher support for online content.... However, the case is different for the developing countries.... hellip; From this paper, it is clear that the application of PEST and SWOT strategic analytical tools can go a long way in enabling the newspaper industry in the developed world to assess the various environmental factors that are contributing to the current trend, and thus adjust the industry to align well with the changes and the present circumstances....
9 Pages (2250 words) Book Report/Review

Real News versus Cosmetic News

This report "Real News versus Cosmetic News" discusses the world that consists of various media houses.... These media houses have diversified their operations to cover a wide source of information and news in print media, television, and the internet through their blogs and other social media sites....
7 Pages (1750 words) Report

Impact of Social Media on the Practice of Journalism

Furthermore, the document focuses on the increasing traffic of receptors as well as the acquisition of trust from the news consumers as per the authority that a journalist acquires from the consumers of the news.... This report "Impact of Social Media on the Practice of Journalism" presents the social media that are not a replacement for journalism....
10 Pages (2500 words) Report

Deception in Journalism

Deception takes place when the journalist transmits information which they know will make the receiver have a given belief and perception on an issue.... What makes the process deceptive in the fact that the identity of the journalist remains secret and the use of recording devices without the subject in question knowing about it....
7 Pages (1750 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us