StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

What Makes a Successful Leader - Essay Example

Summary
The paper 'What Makes a Successful Leader' discusses the statement: “If you don't truly care about people, you should get out of leadership; it will save a lot of people a lot of trouble and maybe even a heart attack” by James Autry the assigned readings by Boyett and Boyett and by Kellerman…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
What Makes a Successful Leader
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "What Makes a Successful Leader"

This paper attempts to critically evaluate the ment: “If you dont truly care about people, you should get out of leadership; it will save a lot of people a lot of trouble and maybe even a heart attack” by James Autry by reviewing the assigned readings by Boyett and Boyett (1998) and by Kellerman (2005). The topic of leadership has indeed attracted many management “gurus” and experts to put forth what they think are the essential traits and attributes that define a successful leader. As the reading by Boyett points out, the business of leadership coaching is a multi-billion dollar enterprise and one that sees a huge churn of books and manuals on the art and science of leadership every year. The focus throughout this paper is to contrast Autry’s statement with the opinions expressed by Boyett and Boyett and Kellerman along with my personal views on what makes a successful leader. The first and foremost task is to define what leadership is and who is a leader? Boyett and Boyett go to great lengths to define a leader from the perspectives of different experts on management. They list several attributes and traits as set forth by the management experts from Drucker to Stephen Covey. There is a whole section in the reading that is devoted to checklists on the attributes and traits of successful leaders. The point here is that the authors do a good job in introducing the topic of leadership by examining the writings of other experts. And as we shall see in the subsequent paragraphs, Boyett and Boyett go further than merely rehashing what other experts have written about leadership and instead devise their own theory of what leadership means. According to Boyett and Boyett, to be a leader means to have i) natural allies or followers ii) have a field of interaction and iii) the process of leadership must occur as an event. The point here is that leadership is something that is a process that occurs in discrete events as well as a continuum that has a common thread tying it all in. the discrete events that typify leadership is the impermanence of leadership that makes Lee Iacocca a president at Ford and then be fired and again rejuvenate as a leader at Chrysler. Hence, the point made by Boyett and Boyett is that leadership need not be permanent as can be seen from the fact that some leaders are leaders today and not leaders tomorrow. However, what ties in leaders into developing traits and attributes that last in all places and contexts is the bond that they have with people. And it is here that Autry’s statement needs to be examined in a thorough manner. As long as leaders have bonds with their followers, the leader is strong and once the bond is broken, the leader’s role ends. Leadership is all about people. This truism may sound like a cliché but it is the case that unless leaders have followers, they cannot be leaders. Hence, the amount of time and effort that leaders invest in cultivating followers determines their success at leadership. As can be seen from the examples of democratic countries, leaders are made and unmade by each election result. This makes it possible for say, Barack Obama to continue his leadership whereas John McCain would be remembered as someone who was a challenger but not yet there. This fickle nature of the “relationship” between the leaders and followers also makes it possible for McCain to reinvent himself in another setting and for Obama to fall from grace because he could not deliver on some of his promises. As Boyett and Boyett put it, there is the question of duties and responsibilities for the leader. They define three such roles: i) strategist to visionary ii) commander to storyteller iii) systems architect to change agent and servant. It is the way in which leaders manage this evolutionary process that determines their success or otherwise. We all love to hear stories about ourselves and about others. Hence, a leader is one who tells a good story that is believable as well as verifiable. Note the emphasis on integrity and authenticity. The use of “Joe the Plumber” by the McCain camp during the 2008 Presidential Election is a good example of how imagery works in the modern leadership context. Till now, we have seen the definition of leadership as given by Boyett and Boyett. However, the twist in the tale is when we consider Kellerman’s article on Leadership which deals with the question of bad leadership and the reason for followers to continue following bad leaders. While Boyett and Boyett have expounded on what makes a great leader and so on, Kellerman focuses on something that has relevance to the modern world i.e. of leaders having the same failings that all of us and why theory must explain the apparent lack of morals in leaders in whom we have invested so much. She makes the point that the 20th century and the early 21st century have both witnesses leaders who were unethical, immoral and worse cruel as can be seen from the examples she cites of Hitler, Mao, Stalin, Pol Pot on the one extreme and the disgraced CEO’s of Enron, WorldCom and other companies that saw their leaders failing them on the issue of ethics. To return to the thesis statement about leadership being all about people, it is worthwhile to note that just as followers tolerate good leaders, they tolerate bad leaders as well. Hence, Kellerman’s point about a need for a theory to explain this seeming contradiction must be applauded. Though training programs may be conducted and millions of dollars spent on coaching leaders, the disconnect between theory and practice is something that needs elaboration and explanation. We all have heard the phrase “in the real world” often. In my opinion, this represents a demarcation between what we read in the books and how it is “out there”. Hence, “in the real world” leaders cook books, have affairs and just about do everything that theory states they should not do. Both Boyett and Boyett and Kellerman challenge mainstream notions of leadership in different ways. Whereas Boyett and Boyett seem to distinguish the traits of leaders as given by mainstream experts from those that appear to be closer to reality, Kellerman goes one step further and questions the basis of mainstream discourse about leadership. She does so by pointing out the spate of corporate scandals that have shaken the US and wonders whether the management experts have got it wrong. While it is certainly not the case that theory can be totally wrong, it must be remembered that at most times, it is best an approximation of real world behavior with the good guys always winning. My understanding of business leadership is that leadership is situational, context dependant and a balancing act. A good leader adapts to the situation and there is no “right” way that applies to all situations. Hence, a leader is one who is nimble to spot the opportunities and act on them. The statement that leadership is all about people is indeed valid in so far as the above qualifiers of situation, context and balance between competing stakeholders are taken into consideration. In conclusion, the readings are indeed illuminating as they stimulate thinking and throw open several issues that need to be debated in order to arrive at a nuanced understanding of leadership. These readings have certainly helped me frame the issue of leadership in perspective. References Boyett, J.H & Boyett, J.T. (1998). Leadership. In The guru guide: the best ideas of the top management thinkers). New York: John Wiley & Sons Inc, pp. 1-44 Kellerman, B. (2005). Leadership - Warts and all. In Harvard Business Review on The mind of the leader. Boston: Harvard Business School Press, pp. 1-13. Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF What Makes a Successful Leader

Why is Bill Gates a successful leader

Why is Bill Gates a successful leader?... (7 Key Lessons from a Greatest leader of all times - Bill Gates | Life of Excellence) 4.... (Manager's Role in successful Motivation:... A Clear Vision Bill Gates knows that in order to move forward he can leave no man behind, to ensure this he has a clear vision not only in his mind but he also makes certain to pass it on to his employees.... Such confidence makes the work environment not only positive but also fun where employees go an extra mile to achieve results....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

How Could Leader Be Ethical

Concurrently, a successful leader must keep both ends of the communication channel open and available round the clock.... The paper "How Could leader Be Ethical?... Therefore, ethical leadership is important as this is what differentiates between a capable leader and an incompetent one.... Most of us simply define it as 'being led by a leader with the good character'.... Respect for values, a strong character, ability to listen, understand, mentor, and navigate along with integrity and courage are just some of the basic qualities a leader should possess (Ciulla, 2007)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

What makes a Good Leader Popular Theories of Leadership

Therefore the team leader has to be a good learner, so that he can capitalize on the stronger points of the team while trying to minimize the effects of weaker points.... Pascale (1990) wrote that "managers do things right, while leaders do the right thing," A leader is supposed to be; ... egotiator: The negotiating skills are the one's which distinctly differentiate a leader from other members.... While stuck up in a tricky situation a leader uses his skills to convince the concerned people, tries to extract reasonable benefits for his team mates and negotiates a better deal from suppliers while weighing the outcomes of different alternatives....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Leadership: The Power of Belief

Leadership theories are the theories that study different aspects of leadership and come up with the ideas of What Makes a Successful Leader.... The qualities of decision making, motivating people, understanding their needs, and being flexible are very important for being a successful leader.... The truth is, leaders are not leaders right from birth, but their lives and their beliefs make them the leader.... Some theories like Contingency theory focuses more on the different situations that affect leadership while theories like 'situational theory' focus more on the behavior pattern of a leader in a particular situation....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

What Makes a Good Leader

"what makes a Good Leader" paper states that a good leader is vital for any organization.... In order to be a good leader, there are certain traits that are described in this paper such as communication, motivation, ideal character, confidence, and passion.... Motivation is another crucial aspect of a good leader because a motivated worker displays more enthusiasm to work along with superior performance and excellence.... good leader must possess an ideal character....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Outline of Leadership Styles

What Makes a Successful Leader.... What Makes a Successful Leader.... In this paper, I will expound on a wide range of major types of leadership styles, the characteristics of a successful leader,.... In this paper, I will expound on a wide range of major types of leadership styles, the characteristics of a successful leader, the effects that a good leader has on others, and how to become a good leader.... The characteristics of a successful leader are responsibility, understanding nature, and harmonious co-existence with followership....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Challenges Faced By Healthcare Leaders In Terms Of Decision Making Within the Team Environment

In order to become a successful leader in the healthcare industry, a person should be able to improve the quality of healthcare provided to patients, develop and implement strategies to motivate healthcare staff, and ensure the healthcare organizations they run are managed well and demonstrate accountability for their use of resources.... This paper is aimed at providing a comparative study of team-centred versus leader-centred leadership.... It is necessary for a leader to formulate strategies based on the needs of the patients in order to make sure that all patients are able to receive quality healthcare services....
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment

Successful Leadership Skills - Qualities that Make the Leader of the 21ST Century

This report "Successful Leadership Skills - Qualities that Make the leader of the 21ST Century" discusses traits and qualities like honesty, empathy, compassion, inspiration, and most importantly communication can make the difference in this war-ridden world.... The specific traits, be they inherent or learned of any leader set him apart from the rest of the crowd.... Honesty is a leader who is of extreme significance.... Honesty finds its roots in behavioral theory, according to which, the traits of a leader can be learned rather than being inherited....
7 Pages (1750 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us