StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Life of a Prisoner in the Soviet Gulag and Nazi Death Camp Systems - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay describes that prison life is miserable and oppressive in ways that are known to fundamentally change individuals. In the last century, two of the worst places in which to be imprisoned were the death camps of World War II and the Gulag of the Soviet Union…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
Life of a Prisoner in the Soviet Gulag and Nazi Death Camp Systems
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Life of a Prisoner in the Soviet Gulag and Nazi Death Camp Systems"

Life of a Prisoner in the Soviet Gulag and Nazi Death Camp Systems Prison life, in any country and under any historical framework, is miserable andoppressive in ways that are known to fundamentally change individuals who endure the hardships involved. In the last century, two of the worst places in which to be imprisoned were the death camps of World War II and the Gulag of the Soviet Union. In Primo Levi’s book,. Survival in Auschwitz, a poignant portrait of a man who suffered the indignities and tribulations of surviving incarceration in the prison camp Auschwitz is developed. Just as engaging is the book by Solzhenitsyn, One Day in the Life of Ivan Deisovich, which portrays a fictionalized account of his personal experiences. Through explorations about these two accounts and expanded upon through other sources, a comparison of the experiences in Auschwitz and the Gulag can be made. One of the notable things about Solzhenitsyn’s work is that there is little that truly occurs in the book. The novel tells the details of a day, slowly and methodically, so that the mundane nature of life in a prison is revealed. Although there is some discussion of punishment and the cruelty of living in the Gulag, it is the monotony and the long day that has the most impact. Through the oppressive atmosphere and the indignity of being given no trust through constant searches and counting of the inmates, there is a sense of being held in place, that feeling permeating the whole work in a way that portrays a realistic feeling of being in prison. In contrast, the life that Levi Primo describes is filled with hardships that are terrible and not mundane. Each new indignity pushes him toward the next lowered level in which he must re-establish some sense of humanity into his life. The strongest concept that creates the biggest differences in the experiences that are described is that in the Gulag, while life is harsh, there does seem to be some hope that the next day will come, and that finally the protagonist will be released from his imprisonment. In Auschwitz, on the other hand, there is the pervading sense that there will be only death at the end of the journey. Hope is a much more precious commodity as the descriptions of the daily life is defined by the knowledge that genocide had been the original agenda of the Nazi party. The low level of human conditions emphasized the lack of respect for basic human existence that was provided in this terrible place. In the Gulag, while demoralizing events were a daily part of life, the intention seemed to contain and maintain the prisoners, rather than to encourage death to take them. According to German records about the numbers of deaths in Auschwitz, 1,750,000 people died in the camp (Linn 71). The camp had a finite life, its beginning and end within the time frame of World War II. Its purpose was to facilitate the genocide of those the Nazi regime had determined were unfit as representative of the human species, and were defined as expendable and ideologically unnecessary. The horror of this concept and the number of people lost to this belief system makes it one of the worst events in human history. Where the events at Auschwitz were terrible, the camp only existed in a few short years where the atrocities had a finite beginning and end. The Gulag system, on the other hand, lasted for thirty years in which slow systems of horror and oppression wore down the people from the threat of being detained within its grasp, or the actuality of being detained. The Gulag represented fear for those who were not in its walls, promoting the oppression of Communism and holding sway over the expression of belief and opinion within the nation of the Soviet Union (Applebaum). Cleanliness, health, and food were all some of the more important themes from both writers. Health was not easily kept in either environment, the health of Levi being so poor in the end that he was left behind, which more than likely saved his life from the harsh journey of the other prisoners. When the Soviet’s liberated the camp, he was able to regain his health and become free. As Denisovich discusses his life, he relates that he cannot be seen because the list for the day has been filled. His health is measured by the number of others who are before him having their own needs fulfilled. Food, as well, is an issue that must be addressed in both styles of imprisonment. The spoon, for Levi, represents his need for food and that in owning the spoon he has some attachment to a sense of control over his diet. It is only symbolic as he suffers from starvation, but it represents the importance of food. Solzhenitsyn writes about Denisovich as he finds way to get more food, getting control over his life by being clever and through stealing, which represents the way in which the environment can change the values of an individual. For Levi, the act of bathing, even though the water was filthy, represented a control in maintaining the sense of human living. In both stories, the little luxuries, that most would take for granted, made the difference in how they viewed their situations. Both Auschwitz and the Gulag were terrible places and it is difficult to truly tell of the experiences as they pressures that they put on the individuals was designed to dehumanize and oppress the existence of being human. The events in Auschwitz were defined by the sense that their existence in that camp was the end and that death was inevitable. For Denisovich in the Gulag, there was some sense that to endure was to reach an end with the hope of release. The threat of dying, however, hung eminent in Auschwitz, but always looming in the Gulag in a much slower process. For those who had to endure either of these systems, the threat to life was real and a part of daily life. Both prove that what a human can endure is well beyond that which can be imagined by those who never experience such oppression. Works Cited Applebaum, Anne. Gulag: A History. New York [etc.: Anchor, 2003. Print. Levi, Primo. Survival in Auschwitz. United States: BN Publishing, 2007. Print. Lînn, Rût. Escaping Auschwitz: A Culture of Forgetting. Ithaca, NY [u.a.: Cornell Univ. Press, 2004. Print. Solzhenit︠s︡yn, Aleksandr I, and Ralph Parker. One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich. New York: Signet Classic, 1998. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Life of a Prisoner in the Soviet Gulag and Nazi Death Camp Systems Essay”, n.d.)
Life of a Prisoner in the Soviet Gulag and Nazi Death Camp Systems Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1596078-life-of-a-prisoner-in-the-soviet-gulag-and-nazi-death-camp-systems
(Life of a Prisoner in the Soviet Gulag and Nazi Death Camp Systems Essay)
Life of a Prisoner in the Soviet Gulag and Nazi Death Camp Systems Essay. https://studentshare.org/history/1596078-life-of-a-prisoner-in-the-soviet-gulag-and-nazi-death-camp-systems.
“Life of a Prisoner in the Soviet Gulag and Nazi Death Camp Systems Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1596078-life-of-a-prisoner-in-the-soviet-gulag-and-nazi-death-camp-systems.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Life of a Prisoner in the Soviet Gulag and Nazi Death Camp Systems

The True Purpose of the Gulags

This research paper "The True Purpose of the Gulags" determines to what extent the government agency that administered to penal labor camps of the soviet Union was under Stalin Death camps rather than labor Camps and evaluates the true purpose of the Gulags under the rule of Stalin.... any times, it became physically impossible for a prisoner to handle the exhaustive physical labor and he simply could not go on.... These prisoners were often whipped or beaten to death because it was taken by those who ran the labor camp that the person was refusing to follow orders....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Concentration Camps of Nazi Germany

The first camp that was created in Nazi Germany was opened two months after Adolf Hitler took power in January 1933.... The camp, called Dachau, was considered a triumph for the German people because the people were in need of order in their country (Bergen).... This camp was considered a solution to the chaos that had previously existed.... Some of the prisoners were brutal convicts from traditional prisons who were given the power over other prisoners in order to make the job of the camp guards an easier task (Bergan)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Exploration of Nazi Captivity

“A man enters and offers some concise information - Buna, a work camp of about 10,000 prisoners, near Auschwitz in Upper Silesia.... Before Hitler's death, he uttered, “Brutal force has not won anything durable.... The essay "Exploration of nazi Captivity" comments on military historical events concerning nazi slavery.... rdquo; nazi slavery or American chattel slavery was an alternative beat of the same wicked heart, against the races that were at a highly disadvantageous position....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Female Nazi War Criminals

There were low esteemed and notorious camp guards just like Irma Grese and Ilse Koch.... The holocaust that was inflicted upon European Jews by the nazi administration was the most sadistic and systematic project of mass genocide that had ever mounted.... Adolf Hitler has been held responsible for this, as one of the most sanguinary and psychotic leaders in history… After hearing the word nazi, the image it brings up in a mind is of a young man who is more likely to be dressed in an authoritative uniform and a red armband....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

How was Nazi Concentration Camp worser than Soviet Concentration Camps

According to rough estimation the people perished at the hands of Hitler is somewhere around 11 million and these were non-combatants, whereas people who lost their lives in gulag and other territories between 1933 and 1945 (where Stalin regime was in power) is somewhere around between 2 and 3 million.... In reality, both camps were horrible in their entirety, however; it is the Nazi concentration camp that left irremovable horror marks on the world human psychology....
2 Pages (500 words) Movie Review

Prison Life and Strategies

The author examines the purpose of the prisons in the US justice system, the current condition of the prisons, protection of a prisoner upon release and measures to protect public upon prisoner's release… The author states that prison is a sad realistic need of the criminal justice system.... Prison is the last solution to the criminal the justice systems have....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Escape from Camp 14

Escaping from camp 14 is an impossible feat since not only the attempted escapees but also witnesses were subjected to harshest kinds of torture.... However, due to luck and courage Shin Dong-Hyuk was the… Till his early 20s, Shin was captivated in camp 14.... For Shin, the world was what existed within the walls of camp 14.... Since he was born and brought up in a concentration camp, he accepted the brutal manners as values of life more because he was never exposed to the civilized world outside the walls of camp 14, “he called it home” (Harden, 4)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Israeli Air Force at Auschwitz and Gulag Archipelago Documentary

It depicts the soviet repression and suffering of men, women, and children in labor camps.... The statement read, "We pilots of the Air Force, flying in the skies above the camp of horrors, arose from the ashes of the millions of victims and shoulder their silent cries, salute their courage and promise to be the shield of the Jewish people and its nation Israel (OSullivan, 2003).... The Russian prisoners of war in German also formed part of the victims in the camp....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us