StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Animals as Friends, not Scientific Experiments - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name Name of Professor Animals are Friends, not Scientific Experiments Introduction Sooner or later, animal use in scientific research will end. Animal experimentation is inhumane, hence it should be stopped. It may come to an end due to changing ethical and political perspective…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.6% of users find it useful
Animals as Friends, not Scientific Experiments
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Animals as Friends, not Scientific Experiments"

Download file to see previous pages

As argued by philosopher David DeGrazia (1996), “The path to the ethical treatment of animals runs through their minds” (p. 76). His argument stress the value of taking into consideration animals’ mental being, such as their self-consciousness, intelligence, recognition, and ability to feel pleasure and pain, in evaluating the ethical implications of animal experimentation. If the wellbeing of animals rests in his/her emotions, and if such emotions are the mechanism of the mind, then all genuine moral debate over animal welfare should one way or another consider what is in the minds of these animals.

DeGrazia (1996) argues, “What sorts of mental capacities we attribute to animals have a great deal to do with how we think they should be treated” (p.1). The argument of DeGrazia is compelling because it poses crucial and interconnected issues. First, is there truly a difference between the physical and the mental in animal welfare? Are hunger and pain, which are primary concerns of animal welfare, truly associated with the minds of animals? Or are these welfare concerns physical, or a union of the mental and the physical?

This paper begins with Albert Schweitzer’s perspective of animal welfare that does not depend on evaluating the mental capabilities of animals, to identify his contribution to the resolution of certain cases of animal experimentation. Albert Schweitzer suggested respect for life as a guideline for interacting with and relating to our environment. According to Schweitzer, an ethical man “does not ask how far this or that life deserves sympathy as valuable in itself, nor how far it is capable of feeling.

To him life as such is sacred. He shatters no ice crystals that sparkles in the sun, tears no leaf from its tress, breaks off no flower, and is careful not to crush any insect as he walks” (Carbone 2004, 48). This statement is inspiring, but does it contribute to the resolution of the issue on how and when to research or test on animals? Could the ‘ethical man’ ethically inflict pain on animals for scientific research? Evidently, Schweitzer says yes to the latter question because he is not a critic of animal experimentation.

He argues (Carbone 2004, 48): Those who experiment upon animals by surgery and drugs, or inoculate them with diseases in order to be able to help mankind by the results obtained, should never quiet their consciences with the conviction that their cruel action may in general have a worthy purpose. In every single instance they must consider whether it is really necessary to demand of an animal this sacrifice for men. And they must take anxious care that the pain be mitigated as much as possible.

He proposed that life should be respected and valued, irrespective of its position on any human hierarchy. However, he acknowledged the special need to draw a line between when to save a life and give up another, but gave practically no instruction for these decisions. By placing his entire focus on the ethical man’s attributes instead on those to whom this ‘ethical man’ should pay moral attention to Schweitzer contributes insignificantly to the cases of animal welfare. Science and technology have their limitations and cannot resolve the ethical issues entrenched in nearly all animal welfare discussions.

For example, not every suffering or pain can be presently cured with medicines. What degree of pain requires stopping a scientific resear

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Animals as Friends, not Scientific Experiments Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1438889-should-the-animals-be-used-for-scientific-research
(Animals As Friends, Not Scientific Experiments Essay)
https://studentshare.org/english/1438889-should-the-animals-be-used-for-scientific-research.
“Animals As Friends, Not Scientific Experiments Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1438889-should-the-animals-be-used-for-scientific-research.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Animals as Friends, not Scientific Experiments

The Use of Animals in the Experiments

He argued that the severe harm and physiological pain caused to the non-human animals as a result of the dissections conducted during the experiments cause a physiological imbalance to the animals which go unnoticed.... The increase in experiments with the use of animals resulted in an increase in the vivisection of the animals.... hellip; The experimentation on animals is an age-old phenomenon in which the non-human animals are used in the process of experiments that range from pure observation of the animals to experimental investigations depending on the objective of the experiments....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Psychology: Is It a Science

Science, as wee know it, is concerned with experiments and measurements.... One of the first persons to perform systematic experiments to study physical phenomena was Galileo.... He studied motion by doing some well designed experiments, and discovered that all objects, whether made of heavy or lighter material, fall to the ground with the same acceleration.... Scientific methods of research generally follow some basic steps- 1) Observing nature or natural phenomena 2) classifying the collected information 3) Performing experiments 4) using logic to make a hypothesis 5) expressing the result in mathematical formulae, and modeling with the help of computers....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

ANIMAL SCIENTIFIC EXPERIMENTS

Efforts made by various scientists to understand functioning of the body can be attributed to the animal experiments, which are some of the traditional approaches (Collins, 2013, 1).... In fact, identifying the functioning of the body focuses on the heath and during illness, and… Moreover, numerous scientific objectives are achieved through animal experiments, though there are alternative methods such as computer models and cell cultures, thereby offering information that is Animal experiments are considered very useful for the last centuries, whereby they are applied in physiological studies and processes....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Testing on Animals. Some people are FOR and some people are against

Also known as in vivo testing, testing on animals involves using non human animals for experiments.... According to ProCon (2014), roughly 26 million animals are subjected to research tests for commercial or scientific purposes in the United States of America alone annually.... My interest in the topic of testing on animals has been drawn by a documentary that I recently watched about the process… From the documentary, I learnt that before drugs are tested on humans, they have to be tested on animals....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Theories of Social Psychology Implied by Derren Brown

The paper "Theories of Social Psychology Implied by Derren Brown" states that there are bigger experimental groups that can participate in experiments bringing a more significant amount of data, and there are also new greater possibilities to convey the study results to a mass public.... arious experiments have been studied and experimented with in the field of social psychology to explain a phenomenon within scientific terms.... The reasons for these targets are experiments firstly have a tendency to be made by non-scientific professionals, as a hypnotist in the case of Derren Brown....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Animal Testing and Experimentation

These tests and experiments have discovered a myriad of cures and treatments for diseases that were once considered incurable such as carcinomas, polio,… Along with these experiments, scientists have also developed alternate treatments which have yielded breakthroughs minimizing painful side-effects of human illnesses.... On the other hand, there are many people who consider animal testing as cruelty being inflicted upon the animals, the issue of selfishness is also another reason that these experiments are considered wrong because of the fact that we hurt the animals just to gain benefit for our own self....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Animal Behavior and Animal Welfare

In the paper “Animal Behaviour and Animal Welfare” the author has deplored the scientific and statistical inhuman evaluation of animal behavior which he believes is the outcome of the scientific community relying more on analysis of quantitative evaluation methods.... The author in his introduction highlights the limited purview within which the scientific community has confined its observation of animal behavior so as to satisfy and meet its own selfish criteria in the garb of scientific research....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

Ethics of Animal and Human Germline Genetic Modification

Therefore, a research team should be very keen in their endeavors and ensure that they carefully observe the animals for any undesirable signs.... The use of animals for conducting tests usually has many adverse effects, with some of them dying after experiencing a lot of pain....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us