StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Soviet Montage Editing and History - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the paper ‘Soviet Montage Editing and History” the author analyses Soviet Cinema, which is a very unique entity of cinematic establishment for its great contribution to the innovation of contemporary cinemas today. One of the remarkable contributions of the Soviet Cinema is the Soviet Montage…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful
Soviet Montage Editing and History
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Soviet Montage Editing and History"

Soviet Montage Editing and History "The cinema is for us the most important of the arts." - Vladimir Lenin Soviet Cinema is a very unique entity of cinematic establishment for its great contribution in the innovation of the contemporary cinemas today. One of the remarkable contributions of the Soviet Cinema is the Soviet Montage. Montage is a French word meaning "putting together" or an "assembly". It is one of the techniques of film editing. Soviet filmmakers of the 20's formulated the Soviet Montage in order to deliver effectively a message that cannot be done in continuity editing (Karpenko 2002). There are three senses of the film on how to use and execute montage technique by its terminology. First, from its original root of French film practice, the term refers to the identification of the movie's editor. Secondly, Soviet filmmakers used "montage" in the 1920's as method of juxtaposing shots to derive new meaning as a concealed message to convey that was not apparent to the scene. Third is the "montage sequence" usage usually done by the Hollywood filmmakers to condense fashionably a narrative segment in a film (Smith 2004). Lev Kuleshov was the first Soviet filmmaker who used the Soviet Montage. For him, it is an art really meant for film editing and cannot be done in other medium. Sergie Eisenstein views this as a tool or an electricity to be used to shock the audience (Risse 2007). This theory of editing innovated from its simple nature to the more intelligent execution being formulated and executed in present international cinemas. The progression of the editing theory varies from different filmmakers' views and responsibilities (Karpenko 2002). History. During the great depression period of Russia from the Tsar catastrophe the artistic flair of Russian filmmakers also rage along with it. Filmmaking that time was encouraged and greatly supported by a Union Socialist leader Vladimir Lenin (Smith 2004). Lev Kuleshov was among the very first to theorize the effectiveness of using film as a medium to convey various relevant messages of socialism. For Kuleshov, editing is like a brick by construction of the building. In this case, it's a shot by shot in order to construct a film (Smith 2004). Between 1919 and 1924, Kuleshov conducted certain montage experiments that eventually then influenced other Russian filmmakers. The necessity to do such was due to the shortage of the stock of the film (Bordwell 1972). In its early period, this method of editing was then called a Kuleshov Experiment. He justified that Montage was more effective in message delivery as viewers can easily discern it by context. Kuleshov explained that visual materials depicted can help the viewers to reach the certain conclusions and messages (Smith 2004). In the 1920's, Soviet filmmakers had their own personal opinions on how to execute montage. It was Sergei Einsenstein, a former student of Kuleshov, who marked a note with his own montage execution (Murch 2001). The remarkable note Einsenstein regarded for the montage as he described it as "the nerve of the cinema". He elaborated that "montage is an idea that arises from the collision of not text to the other, but on the top of the other". With this view, thus Soviet Montage had been noted in film editing from them on (Murch 2001). U.S. film director D.W. Griffith, although not part of the montage school, was one of the credited contributors of Soviet Montage for his own approach of power of editing. He used cross cut editing and codifying film grammar. His works were acknowledge by Kuleshov and other Soviet filmmakers, thus helped them to have wider view on film editing (Smith 2004). Sergei Eisenstein viewed montage as a dialectical medium of creating and conveying meaning. He was merely the first one to develop a system of editing that was not concerned with continuity system's rule and technicalities. He called his own montage as "Intellectual Montage". Intellectual Montage Editing. Sergei Eisenstein believed that editing was the foundation of the art of film. He called his editing as dialectical montage as it aimed to expose the essentials of existence of the matter viewed from its political standpoint (Thompson 2002). Eisenstein's Intellectual Montage is the juxtaposition of two shots to produce an idea or an image to convey a message. The shots may or may not correspond to each other, but it has a relationship working on its visual delivery (Karpenko 2002). Eisenstein expressed that the shots should be independent from one another. Shots shall call attention to the composition force of the film. Quoting Sergei he described it as "shopwindow full of pretty but unrelated products." (Thompson 2002). Methods of Montage Editing. Aside from the Intellectual Montage, Soviet Montage also regarded several method of editing. Each method represents different characteristics and nature of montage (Dmytryk 1984). Metric method is an editing that follows a specific number of frames. This is considering the time element of the scene to edit, as well as the emotional reactions in the audience. An example of this is Eisenstein's film October (Dmytryk 1984). Rhythmic method of editing refers to the cutting based on time. In doing this editing method, the visual compositions of the shot, together with various speed of the metric cut are to be considered. This effect is to induce more complex meanings beyond the necessity of the metric montage. The sound is also very vital to complete the method fully in rhythmic mode, including sound and music. An example of this is the The Battleship Potemkin's sequence of "Odessa steps" by Eisenstein as well (Dmytryk 1984). Tonal method uses the emotional definition of the shots or the scene. This effect is to elicit a reaction from the audience for its further effectiveness. In The Battleship Potemkin's clip after the death of Vakulinchuk, a martyr for sailors and workers, the emotional execution highlighted the scene (Dmytryk 1984). The Overtonal and Associational method refers to the totality of metric, rhythmic, and tonal montage method to balance message. This is effectively done with more abstract and artistic executions. An example of this method is the film Mother by Pudovkin (Dmytryk 1984). Pudovkin. Perhaps Vsevolod Pudovkin was the third Soviet thinker of the Soviet Montage apparent to his previous works. Pudovkin, like Eisenstein was a student of Kuleshov. They were contemporaries at the same time rivals for the development of the Kuleshov Effect or Experiment (Evans 2007). Pudovkin was the strong critic of Eisenstein's theory of dialectical montage. His idea of montage was the exact opposite of non-relative images used in editing. He followed the brick by brick construction of Kuleshov but in his own method, the images or shots should be related to one another, or has as association (Evans 2007). In conclusion, no matter how contradicting the views of three thinkers of the Soviet Montage, the endpoint of this are the great contribution it brought to the contemporary cinemas of today. Works Cited Bordwell, David. The Idea of Montage in Soviet Art and Film. Cinema Journal Vol. 11 No. 2. Spring 1972. Cambridge: Harvard University Press Dmytryk, Edward. On Film Editing: An Introduction to the Art of Film Construction. 1984.Focal Press. Boston Evans, Jo. Pudovkin and the Censors: Juan Antonio Bardem's Muerte de un ciclista. Hispanic Research Journal Vol. 8, No. 3. June 2007. University College London Karpenko, Paul. Soviet Cinema and the Art of Montage. 17 Nov 2002. University of Illinois Murch, Walter. In the Blink of an Eye: a Perspective on Film Editing. 2nd Rev. Ed. 2001. Silman-James Press Risse, Derek. Einsenstein, not Einstein. The Rhetoric of Pleasure. English Web. 14 Feb 2007. 21 Nov 2007 Smith, Greg M. Moving Explosions: Metaphors of Emotion in Sergei Eisentstein's Writings. Quarterly Review of Film and Video. 2004 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Soviet Montage Editing and History Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words, n.d.)
Soviet Montage Editing and History Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1524381-discuss-the-history-of-one-film-teqnique-for-example-montage-closeups-sound-give-the-argument-of-three-different-thinkers-on-the-subject-using-at-leat-three
(Soviet Montage Editing and History Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Soviet Montage Editing and History Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1524381-discuss-the-history-of-one-film-teqnique-for-example-montage-closeups-sound-give-the-argument-of-three-different-thinkers-on-the-subject-using-at-leat-three.
“Soviet Montage Editing and History Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1524381-discuss-the-history-of-one-film-teqnique-for-example-montage-closeups-sound-give-the-argument-of-three-different-thinkers-on-the-subject-using-at-leat-three.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Soviet Montage Editing and History

Soviet Montage and Use of Reality in Films

When looking at Soviet film of the 1920s, it can be seen that techniques such as the soviet montage were applied to create a deeper meaning.... Defining the soviet montage The concept of the soviet montage began in the 1920s with the focus on editing specific scenes within movies and combining this with other scenes to create fractured images for the overall plot line.... The first historical presence of the montage began with editing between scenes, specifically which would move from long shots that would be followed by a cut in black....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Studies in International Film Critical Analysis

The paper "Studies in International Film Critical Analysis" tells us about soviet montage School and the German expressionist cinema and Hollywood Cinema.... The soviet montage: Cinema had evolved a language through the classics of Edwin Porter (The Great Train Robbery – 1905) and D.... Battleship Potemkin made in 1925 carries all the five types of montages at different stages of the development of the film and hence is a textbook for the soviet montage theory....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Primary criticisms of American Cinema and Griffith's montage by Sergei Eisenstein

Griffith has provided certain movies that defined the base grammar of cinema and editing.... One very important part of that criticism was Eisenstein's criticism of Griffith's theory of montage.... In the modern day theory of montage Sergei Eisenstein's assumption for montage are widely accepted for providing a ground for cinematic understanding for fast cutting and expression through montages.... As followers to Griffith's theories Sergei Eisenstein had developed montage theory according to his philosophical set back based in Hegel and Marx....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

FILM MOVEMENTS, GENRES, STYLES: Soviet Montage

Film Movement: soviet montage Due Introduction By October 1917 after Russian Revolution, the government of Russia had a difficult task in controlling life sectors.... This led to the faster production of films hence development of innovative edition, stylistic options and editing.... Moscow established a film state that helped in the making of great film makes and emergency of montage.... Most significant development occurred in the soviet film making industry in 1918 hence brought the departure of ‘agit train'....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Eisenstein and the Cinema of Montage

In terms of modern scholarship, a review of the soviet montage method typically focuses on the contribution of Eisenstein, for his was the most brazen and distinct use of the method.... owever, this is not simply a paper on the history of Soviet silent film-it s an investigation into the significant innovations from this epoch.... Yet it is the development of a distinct theory of montage that still reverberates, and this theme is most apparent in the work of Sergei Eisenstein, most notably in the 1925 film Battleship Potemkin....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Montage Is the Art and Technique of Motion-Picture Editing

outlines the history of OULIPO, which was conceived at the initiative of Raymond Queneau and Franois Le Lionnais: It was born.... According to the Columbia Encyclopedia montage is the art and technique of motion-picture editing in which contrasting shots or sequences are used to affect emotional or intellectual responses.... Recombinant Art with relation to montages and tribute videos Introduction: According to the Columbia Encyclopedia montage is the art and technique of motion-picture editing in which contrasting shots or sequences are used to affect emotional or intellectual responses....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Sergei Eisenstein's Theory of Montage

His film, “The great train robbery” produced in 1903 was a classic and powerful example of montage editing.... he beginning of the history of montage can be summed up in these words; “Edwin.... Montage is a French word and the meaning of this word is merely editing.... isenstein's major film theories are weaved around a basic concept in film making, namely montage.... Griffith further developed and refined the technique, “invented” the close up and perfected parallel montage, the fundamental element of film narrative construction in which two events separated in space but co-existing in time are paralleled to one another for contrast, suspense and tension....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Primary Criticisms of American Cinema and Griffith's Montage by Sergei Eisenstein

hellip; As a very important conflict of cinematic history, those contributions of D.... "Primary Criticisms of American Cinema and Griffith's montage by Sergei Eisenstein" paper states that motivated by Griffith's use of montages in his pioneering movies, Eisenstein had developed his own approach that was also due very much to other Russian theorists like Pudovkin, Dziga Vertov.... One very important part of that criticism was Eisenstein's criticism of Griffith's theory of montage....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us