StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Beauty of Mixing: Hybridization in Advancing Art - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
Your Name Prof’s Name Date The Beuaty of Mixing: Hybridization in Advancing Art There are many people in the world who are devoted to cultural purity. These can range from the hateful (Neo-Nazis and white power people, for instance), to the more thoughtful and concerned, such as people who want to protect indigenous cultures from being overwhelmed by the societies with which they coexist…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.6% of users find it useful
The Beauty of Mixing: Hybridization in Advancing Art
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Beauty of Mixing: Hybridization in Advancing Art"

Prof’s The Beuaty of Mixing: Hybridization in Advancing Art There are many people in the world who are devoted to cultural purity. These can range from the hateful (Neo-Nazis and white power people, for instance), to the more thoughtful and concerned, such as people who want to protect indigenous cultures from being overwhelmed by the societies with which they coexist. Such people would certainly try to decry and stop hybridization of art from occurring. This, however, would be a simplistic, uncritical and unproductive view of art.

The fact is, that whenever cultures collide they will have to work out a whole host of issues that are brought up by such contact. The hybridization in art can, far from being damaging to either society, allow each of them to deal with the consequences of contact with a new culture, critique the interaction occurring between the two peoples in a way that would not be possible if not for such hybridization. One of the most common critiques of hybridization is that it comes from a negative place – a place of appropriation in which one society seeks to make another society subservient to its own by taking what makes them culturally distinctive and integrating it into the dominant society.

This is especially true when societies regard each other as “others” and this “otherness” is one of the main reasons for interest between societies, as was certainly the case in Japan during the era when hybridization of art began (Meech 27). This brings up understandable concerns about issues of colonization, appropriation, and cultural destruction – all things that should be avoided. However, avoiding these things does not necessarily mean avoiding hybridization. Many works owe formal debts to other works despite the fact that they are incredibly original and do many good things to the world of art.

James McNeill Whistler’s Princess in a Land of Porcelain, and Caprice in Purple and Gold: The Golden Screen, for instance, clearly owe a formal debt to Japanese culture. Almost the entire subject matter of the works are Japanese, from the clothing to the panelling, and though it is certainly an identifiably western painting, the flat nature of both works recalls something of Japanese art. While not necessarily as flat or elegant s Hosada Eishi’s The Geisha Itsutomi, it is quite apparent that Whistler was drawing on this style of work in concocting his paintings.

I would argue, however, that far from being appropriative, they serve as a critical analysis of the way in which the west had been engaging in contact with the East. They show western women adorning themselves with all manner of Japanese trappings, but without an actual understanding of Japanese culture – the works depict women playing dress-up, a scathing critique of the way that people had engaged with Japanese culture at that time. James Tissot’s Young Women Looking at Japanese Articles shows that such critiques are possible without resorting to hybridization.

This painting depicts two women dressed in Western style peering at articles of Japanese culture. All at once this painting cleverly critiques the way that Westerner’s had been interacting with Japanese culture – from a distance, as a curiosity, to be taken in to and made part of Western culture, or ridiculed from a distance. The fact that the Japanese largely looked at Western culture through a similar lens (Sullivan 122) does not change the fact that this is not a proper appreciation of a different society.

Thus hybridization is not required for this type of critique necessarily, which weakens the argument for hybrid art. I would argue, however, that they hybridized counterpoints are more poignant. They not only critique forms of appreciation that are damaging in terms of inter-society communication, but also demonstrate a form of communication between societies that can be more productive. They must demonstrate some appreciation for the other culture’s art in order to be able to use some of its language in their own works, which demonstrates a depth and understanding that should be present in dealing with other societies.

Some people will always be upset by clashes of culture. They believe that one culture should remain forever as it is, immovable and so forth. Cultures, however, are highly plastic and will always mold and shift as they come into contact with other cultures. Hybridization is, to some degree, a necessary outcome of such contact. It can provide an appropriate way to both appreciate and critique inter-culture communication, and far from being a bad thing can actually help each culture come to terms with its self and its interaction with others.

Works Cited Sullivan, Michael. Eastern and Western Art. Los Angeles: UCLA UP. 1989. Meech, Julia. “Frank Lloyd Wright and the Art of Japan”

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Beauty of Mixing: Hybridization in Advancing Art Assignment”, n.d.)
The Beauty of Mixing: Hybridization in Advancing Art Assignment. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1455643-cultural-hybridity
(The Beauty of Mixing: Hybridization in Advancing Art Assignment)
The Beauty of Mixing: Hybridization in Advancing Art Assignment. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1455643-cultural-hybridity.
“The Beauty of Mixing: Hybridization in Advancing Art Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1455643-cultural-hybridity.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Beauty of Mixing: Hybridization in Advancing Art

Beauty and the Beast

Morando English 106 March 30, 2012 beauty & the Beast: The Bath Scene I want to focus my queer analysis on the bath scene, for a very important reason.... We also find that instead of being consumed by the off-putting, objectifying lust we might expect, he claims that he cares for beauty but is afraid to confess his love.... Discovering and nurturing his unseen depth will be the duty of beauty, once she accepts his confession of love and proposal of marriage....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Diversity and Global Culture

The American Heritage College Dictionary defines hip hop as, "The popular culture of big city and especially inner city youth, characterized by graffiti art, break dancing, and rap music-of or relating to this culture.... Hip hop music, rap or rap music is a style of popular music, which consists of two main components, namely, rapping or MCing and DJing or audio mixing and scratching....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

What is Beauty and Why We Value Art so Much

In his view a good view about aesthetics depends upon the originality and the beauty of the art works.... Aesthetics may help one to realize the beauty of a piece of art.... It is a common saying in this world that beauty hails from art.... Sensible art and media is the creation of selections arranged by an artist or media maker.... In the olden times art was predicted as a base of beauty; quite a few even avowed that natural beauty is subsidiary to artistic beauty....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Positive Aspects of Hybridization

This paper evaluates various positive and negative aspects of hybridization in the following sections.... In the essay “Positive Aspects of hybridization,” the author analyzes the mating of two different species to give rise to a third that has mixed characteristics from both of the parent species.... The three times hybridization of the prairie sunflower with the common sunflower that results in the generation of three different types of sunflowers, namely the puzzle sunflower, the desert sunflower, and the sand sunflower is one good example....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Nucleic acid hybridisation and Nucleic acid probes

These techniques can be used to distinguish between alleles that vary even by single nucleotides (“Nucleic acid hybridization assays”, 1999, Ch.... ??Nucleic acid hybridization assays”, 1999.... The unique property of nucleic acids to pair with each other through complementary base pairing is the lifeblood of genetic engineering....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Beauty and the Beast

Women in this case beauty and the Beast We live in a very superficial world.... Where women are expected to look a certain way and men are expected to look a certain way as well.... However, it is worse for women because our looks are given a sexual connotation and we are taught that we can only attract the men if we try to… Supermodels have a team of stylists, ordinary women only have a pair of hands....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Beauty and the Beast

Her work on “When we dead awaken: writing as a revision” is basically celebrated for its wide contribution toward modern language association… The artists work was faced with vast challenges emanating from traditional assumptions of literal scholarship (Rich 2).... This was not all, since it prompted the inclusion of women studies and feminist criticism in the wider academia field (Rich 2). It is important to In addition to women equality, Rich also broadened her writing to promote equality for gays, those disenfranchised by race and class (Rich 5)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Beauty and the Beast

She was the beautiful girl in the village, but unaware of her beauty, making her develop an interest in books and adventuring rather than a housewife.... It is a fairy story talking about an affluent trader who lost all his wealth and had to start looking for it through agreeing to… Since this story was written many years ago, there have been many versions that have emanated with some similarities and differences from the original versions....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us