StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

1(a). Discuss Allport and religion- be creative. 1(b). Discuss Catell and factor analysis- be creative - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Bill Maher (HBO host) commented on the video that is recently circulating, by noting that the particular culture interprets Shariah law very strictly in the treatment of women, yet…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.6% of users find it useful
1(a). Discuss Allport and religion- be creative. 1(b). Discuss Catell and factor analysis- be creative
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "1(a). Discuss Allport and religion- be creative. 1(b). Discuss Catell and factor analysis- be creative"

November Allport and Cattell in Application: Gadhafi and the Gingerbread Man Allport and Gadhafi A current event that has captured public interest recently is the knife sodomy done to Gadhafi. Bill Maher (HBO host) commented on the video that is recently circulating, by noting that the particular culture interprets Shariah law very strictly in the treatment of women, yet the men who caught Gadhafi instinctively were drawn to sodomize him violently. Maher asks: “But don’t these people have issues?

I mean, when the first thing you do is stick something up the guy’s ass, I feel like it says something about you as a culture, the men in that culture. When you segregate the women and you cover them up and homosexuality becomes sexuality (Poor).” I want to use this event, and this response to the event, to consider, by application, Allport’s perspective on religion. Allport was concerned with religion and prejudice. He looked for purity of religious commitment (Ralph W. Hood 413) and distinguished intrinsic from extrinsic, mature from immature.

He found that intrinsic religious orientation is associated with more tolerance and less prejudice, while extrinsic religious orientation is associated with intolerance and more prejudice, and he found that those “who are indiscriminately proreligious are the most prejudiced of all (Allport and Ross 432).“ Intrinsic means that the person’s religious orientation is based on “genuine, heartfelt, devout faith”, while extrinsic religion means using religion as “a means to an end, such as church attendance to gain social status” (New World Encyclopedia)In Middle Eastern countries where external evidence of religious orientation is required and enforced by authorities, and failure to visibly abide by Shariah law is punishable by death, religious energy is directed away from intrinsic and toward extrinsic, for survival.

This causes distortion in religious experience. The results of this distortion are seen in the event referred to in the beginning of this paper. This is what Bill Maher noted in his response. Allport distinguished immature religion from mature religion. Immature religion involves magical thinking and self-justification, is wish-fulfilling and unreflective, can be fanatic and is literal-minded, is second-hand (uncritically believing whatever one is taught), while mature religion is well-differentiated (critically analyzed and sorted out), dynamic (driven by religious mysteries and realities, not driven by selfish and fearful hungers and impulses), involves consistent morality (value-derived, not punishment avoidant), is comprehensive, integral, and open to new ideas and spiritual growth (Exploring Spiritual Development.com). People whose unreflective fanaticism, magical self-justification, and undifferentiated literalness results in selfish and fearful hunger and impulse enactment, as demonstrated in the violent knife-sodomizing of an overthrown leader, and whose actions are founded on extrinsic religious experience, certainly meet the criteria for Allport’s immature category.

It is no surprise they are intolerant. 2. Cattell and the Gingerbread ManThe second theorist I will consider is Cattell, specifically with attention to his use of factor analysis and 16 Factor Personality Model. Cattell was interested in creating a common, natural language personality taxonomy. He reduced thousands of traits, identified by Allport, to factors (psychometric-success.com). He devised a statistical method for feeding them into a factor analysis formula to yield a replicable description with clear boundaries between categories (Fehringer).

Unfortunately, although his typology was a significant contribution, being replicable and unambiguously bounded have not been strong points of factor analysis (Fehringer). I will use the beloved tale of the Gingerbread Man to illustrate. The Gingerbread man, as you might recall, was not socially compliant with his fate as amusing food, at the whim of the Old Woman. He jumped off the cookie sheet and ran away, chased by the Old Woman (his creator), the Old Man (her partner), animals (domesticated into destiny compliance by the system his creator represents) and villagers (those who have been socialized into supporting social system norms and roles).

Gingerbread men are not human, have no individual rights. It is their socially-accepted role to be eaten, after all, like all gingerbread ancestors before him. Running away positions him as being low range on the primary factors of warmth (detached, cool, non-participatory); rule-consciousness (non-conforming, self-indulgent); sensitivity (utilitarian, self-reliant); privatenss (open, naive, unpretentious); and apprehensiveness (self-assured, unworried, confident, self-satisfied) (Fehringer).

Running away and taunting those who pursue him positions him as high range on the reasoning factor (bright, a fast learner); emotional stability (adaptive, faces reality calmly, higher ego strength); dominance (assertive and stubborn); liveliness (animated, spontaneous, expressive, impulsive); social boldness (bold, venturesome, uninhibited); and openness to change (experimental, liberal, free thinking) (Fehringer). It is difficult to identify his position with respect to vigilance and abstractedness.

He unquestioningly trusts that he can escape the community and his destiny, and seems unsuspecting that harm will come to him in doing so. This is low range positioning on the primary factor of vigilance (Fehringer). On the other hand, he demonstrates vigilance, suspiciousness, skepticism, and distrustful opposition in confronting and negotiating with the fox. Later, however, he is too trusting and is eaten. So is he low range or high range on vigilance? It becomes circumstantially subjective.

Similarly, with respect to the primary factor of abstractedness, the Gingerbread Man is low range (practical and solution-oriented) and also high range (imaginative, impractical) (Fehringer). Again, his positioning becomes circumstantially subjective, and open to interpretation. Furthermore, there is inconsistency in matching the traits allegedly demonstrating a given primary factor. Apparently gingerbread men, like people, are not consistently category-compliant on personality factors. Personality is perhaps not as fixed in the person, as Cattell apparently assumes, but is also, at least in part, a result of social situation, circumstances and interpretation.

People are not mathematically quantifiable. Our response patterns and attitudes are more flexible than a math formula. Furthermore, culture plays a large role in interpreting traits and their meanings. Whether calculating an analysis by hand or by computer, we are a long way from reliable mathematical designation of personality, and behavior prediction based on it. Works CitedAllport, Gordan W. and J. Michael Ross. "Personal Religious Orientation and Prejudice." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 5 (4) (1967): 432-443.

Exploring Spiritual Development.com. "Gordon Allport and Mature Religion." 2009. Exploring Spiritual Development. 30 October 2011 .Fehringer, Heather M. "Contributions and Limitations of Cattells Sixteen Personality Factor Model." May 2004. Personality Research. 30 October 2011 .New World Encyclopedia. "Allport, Gordon." New World Encyclopedia. 29 October 2011 .Poor, Jeff. "Maher: Gadhafi Sodomy Video Suggests Homosexuality Has Become Sexuality in Islamic Culture." The Daily Caller 29 October 2011.

Psychometric-success.com. "Raymond Cattell (1905-1998)." 2009. Psychometric Sucess. 30 October 2011 .Ralph W. Hood, Jr. "The Conceptualization of Religious Purity in Allports Typology." Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 24 (4) (1985): 413-417.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“1(a). Discuss Allport and religion- be creative. 1(b). Discuss Catell Essay”, n.d.)
1(a). Discuss Allport and religion- be creative. 1(b). Discuss Catell Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1582810-1a-discuss-allport-and-religion-be-creative-1b-discuss-catell-and-factor-analysis-be-creative
(1(a). Discuss Allport and Religion- Be Creative. 1(b). Discuss Catell Essay)
1(a). Discuss Allport and Religion- Be Creative. 1(b). Discuss Catell Essay. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1582810-1a-discuss-allport-and-religion-be-creative-1b-discuss-catell-and-factor-analysis-be-creative.
“1(a). Discuss Allport and Religion- Be Creative. 1(b). Discuss Catell Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1582810-1a-discuss-allport-and-religion-be-creative-1b-discuss-catell-and-factor-analysis-be-creative.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF 1(a). Discuss Allport and religion- be creative. 1(b). Discuss Catell and factor analysis- be creative

Factor-Analytic Trait Models of Personality

In the paper “factor-Analytic Trait Models of Personality” the author analyzes The Pen, Big Five and 16PF models of personality.... The PEN, Big Five and 16PF are the best known factor-analytic trait theories.... All of them are aimed at determining “which of the thousands of traits are most important by using the statistical technique of factor analysis” and making psychology more scientific and mathematical.... allport as a reaction against Freud's excessive emphasis on hidden motifs of humans....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Creative imagination

Both discuss Kant at length, including his thoughts on how the imagination is However, the two philosophers' approaches to Kant differ in several fundamentally different ways: while Singer presents Kantian ideas in fluid form, embedded in the context of a linear history developing the concept of the “aesthetic”, Warnock presents Kant analytically: developing Kantian ideas in a systematic, step-by-step fashion....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Quality Management as a Global Issue

The reporter casts light upon the fact that quality management has become a global issue with more and more organizations from different sectors and from different structures trying to focus on quality issues.... hellip; Organizations are attempting to align their strategy with quality concerns and objectives in order to attain sustained competitive advantage....
34 Pages (8500 words) Essay

Creation Myths of Religion

The questions like when did the universe start to exist, whether it was there always etc are controversial ones and nobody was… Science has put forward Big Bang like many evolution theories of universe; however none of theories succeeded fully in explaining the origin of this universe.... In fact scientific theories increased the doubts further rather For example, big bang theory succeeded partially in explaining the evolution of universe....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Creating Your Own Religion

Religion refers to the kind of faith that a person has in something, and the belief that he or she extracts out in the name of that very faith; According to the dictionary, religion refers to ‘the belief in and worship of a superhuman controlling power, especially a personal… d or gods.... Millions of years ago, a number of religions came into existence and people all around the world attached themselves to whichever religion they felt was acceptable to them and brought them peace and harmony in their lives. Christianity, Judaism, Hinduism, Buddhism All these faiths teach people how to believe in themselves and understand the true meaning of one's existence on this planet....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Allports and Cattells use and theory

Cattell developed the theory as established by allport and came up with fewer words that can be used to describe personality.... Using the factor analysis, Cattell was able to identify closely related terms hence reducing the number of personality traits to just 16.... In addition, Cattel developed sixteen personality factor questionnaires (16PF) a tool that is widely used for personality assessment (Plotnik & Kouyoumjian, 2011).... A trait is a stable and enduring characteristic which drive allport's and Cattell's use of trait theory Institute Introduction Trait theory approaches the of personality from the perspective of understanding different traits....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Creative Briefs

The present paper "creative Briefs" investigates the issue of briefs.... According to the text, in the creative brief for Chock Full o'Nuts, the writer is seeking to communicate an idea for the product, which is coffee for home brewing, over its competitors in the coffee shop brands.... nbsp; The writer for Chock Full o'Nuts has been prompted to write the creative brief in order to offer directions on the client's advertisement....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart as a Creative Person

Before shedding light on Mozart's creativity in light of various definitions, creativity theories and academic literature it is highly essential that I put forward my view of the creative personality.... Before proceeding to discuss how, if Mozart was creative at all, it is essential we first understand the definition of creativity.... The famous dictionary Merriam Webster defines creativity as the quality of being creative or the ability to create new and different things....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us