StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Criminology - sociology -philosophy - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
However, Phillipson Argues that Traditional criminology is a failure. This is because the manner of interpretation of this rationale in traditional criminology has raised questions regarding its…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Criminology - sociology -philosophy
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Criminology - sociology -philosophy"

THE SHORT HISTORY OF CRIMINOLOGY HAS BEEN A HISTORY OF FAILURE By number: Sociology 9999 Dis analysis Submitted to (Tutor):DateIntroduction Crime tends to have a uniform definition and defines universal application. However, Phillipson Argues that Traditional criminology is a failure. This is because the manner of interpretation of this rationale in traditional criminology has raised questions regarding its affectations to given kinds of objectivity as well as its validity as an independent branch of knowledge (Phillipson:3).

This is because society decides the subject of criminologist; he has limited control over formulating the subject. Traditional criminology has been a failure because it does not understand criminal law, criminal and criminal mind.The short history of criminology has been a history of failureAccording to Phillipson, traditional criminology fails to understand criminal law. The subject matter of criminology is defined by non-criminologists thus placing limits on the discipline (Phillipson:4). Even though criminology is acknowledged as the study of crime and criminals, it fails to understand criminal law because sorts of behaviours that are branded as crimes and the people who are convicted as criminals emerge out of social processes which are independent of the professional criminologists’ activities (Phillipson:3).. Traditional criminology, therefore, has his subject matter given to him through the society’s formal definitions of crime (illegal behaviours).

It is also the society that identifies the individuals who commit criminal acts and not criminal law. In addition, traditional criminology has been a failure because legal definitions of what is a criminal behaviour vary within any society (Phillipson:6).. This is because what is regarded as a crime in a given  society may not be in another because different societies have different definitions of criminal behaviours. For instance, some societies accept homosexual behaviour, gambling and drug use while others consider them criminal offenses.

This, therefore, means that there is no one universal behaviour that is always and everywhere criminal because societies’ reactions to crime change with regards to time and place (Phillipson:5).Traditional criminology has ignored social processes upon which criminal law is made. It however rests upon an implicit acceptance of the legal status quo. This unquestioning acceptance of upheld values limit the questions criminologists ask as well as the answers they get from questions relating to the causes of crimes (Phillipson:7).

This restricts the focus of traditional criminology in search of causes to individuals who were officially convicted of criminal offences. The limited vision of traditional criminology implies that it is incapable of locating the causes of crime or criminals by only studying the convicted criminal population. Traditional criminology assumes that cats of the convicted criminals can only be explained by entirely focussing on the convicted criminals without referring to the encompassing social structure.

It assumes that criminals and criminal acts can be identified by examining the personal biographies of convicted criminals; however, this may not be true because biographical factors which are branded causal may also be found in individuals who are members of non-criminal groups. Further, there is no universal constellation of biographical factors which can sufficiently differentiate convicted criminals from matched non-criminals (Phillipson:8). Traditional criminology failed to understand criminal minds.

This is because the factors and claims which were identified as effective discriminators have so far been abandoned. These claims, for instance, included the ideas that criminals were mentally retarded, biologically superior, maternally deprived, economically deprived, mentally ill or a combination of all these (Phillipson:9). This has been strongly criticised because criminals are very intelligent and uses sophisticated technology. ConclusionPhillipson has shown that traditional criminology is a failure because it is faced with many problems that limit its ability to validate claims in a bid to provide explanations for the crimes committed.

The problem with the criminology is that it fails to understand criminal minds, criminal and criminal law. ReferencePhillipson, M. (1971). Sociological aspects of crime and delinqency. London [u.a.], Routledge & Kegan Paul.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Criminology - sociology -philosophy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Criminology - sociology -philosophy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1661281-criminology-sociology-philosophy
(Criminology - Sociology -Philosophy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Criminology - Sociology -Philosophy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1661281-criminology-sociology-philosophy.
“Criminology - Sociology -Philosophy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1661281-criminology-sociology-philosophy.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Criminology - sociology -philosophy

Evaluate the claim that we should seek to abolish imprisonment

Tony Lawson and Joan Garrod have attempted to define imprisonment in the book Dictionary for sociology, as, “…the incarnation of those convicted of certain types of crime.... Imprisonment, as a major form of punishment to control increasing rate of crime and establish the rule of law in society, has been acknowledged by social scientists, criminologists, jurists and administrative systems since inception of human civilization....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Discuss any 2 of the main theories from the Classical/Neoclassical School of Criminology

criminology theories are facts that have been accepted by… Using criminology theories, criminologists are able to explain the occurrence of crime.... Through these es, it is possible to explain crime in a wider society or at an individual level implying that criminology theories are all-round theories (Akers, 1996).... This essay will therefore discuss major criminology theories.... criminology is a social science whose theories are developed based on human behavior....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Why some persons in society commit crime while most others do not

sociology criminology theory A French mathematician, Adolph Quetelet, came up with different suggestions intended to help explain the occurrence of crime in the society.... lassical criminology theory This is the oldest theory formulated in the 1600s by Cesare Beccaria, a renowned Italian philosopher, to help explain why people engaged in criminal activities.... Positivity criminology theory In this theory, scientific research was incorporated in trying to understand why there are some individuals who engage in criminal activities while others do not....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Critical Thinking as The Intellectual and Disciplined Process

The crux of the matter herein is that all facets of life and their multidisciplinary elements fundamentally rely on critical thinking so that without critical thinking, important and related elements such as problem solving, innovation, investigations, reconnaissance, design, constructive arguments and counterarguments, yet these are the very elements that are essential for the realisation and actualisation of all disciplines relevant to man such as chemistry, biology, physics, accounting, banking and business innovations and management, political science, philosophy, administration, sociology, literature, psychology, theology and religious studies and criminology, among others....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Emile Durkheim on Anomie

I argue that sociology is a science in its own right.... Social facts are matters of sociology, and they are “sui generis” (i.... For Durkheim: Essays in Historical and Cultural sociology.... ?? British Journal of criminology, 42, 729-742....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Womens Violence to Men in Intimate Relationships

British Journal of criminology, 44: 324-349.... This paper therefore establishes my personal reasons for selecting the research and its practical utility for me.... This report will critically appraise the article, emphasising… The subject of domestic violence has generated significant discussion and attention in the media, academic research and the criminal Themes in the literature tend to lean toward identifying the consequences and causes of domestic violence (Johnson and Ferraro, 2000)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Comparison of Symbolic Interactionists

This paper "Comparison of Symbolic Interactionists" discusses several concepts established by Mead and Freud.... The ideology of self, psychoanalysis, social and dinner conflict, mind, and society, as well as other important psychosocial concepts, will be discussed.... hellip; Freud's description of the “self” was done so by the model he set forth of the ego, the alter ego and the id....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Criminology of Pleasure

In the following paper “criminology of Pleasure,” the author discusses human activities and small beginnings of motion which are commonly called endeavor.... And this endeavor, when it is toward something, which causes it, is called appetite or desire.... hellip; The author states that most of man's physical movements are the reaction of the urge related to some desire and for the pursuit of pleasure....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us