StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Nietzsches Account of Aesthetics in the Birth of Tragedy - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "The Nietzsches Account of Aesthetics in the Birth of Tragedy" it is clear that the fact of the matter is that art will continue to grow, will continue to expand, and will continue to leverage different means and mechanisms to express its goals to the viewer…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.2% of users find it useful
The Nietzsches Account of Aesthetics in the Birth of Tragedy
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Nietzsches Account of Aesthetics in the Birth of Tragedy"

Section/# Analysis 2. Analyse the following passage in terms of the Nietzsche’s account of aesthetics in The Birthof Tragedy:   Nietzsche’s “The Birth of Tragedy” takes a somewhat different approach to the exemplification of the then “modern” art that was beginning to come to prominence in the world in which he lived. What is peculiar and interesting about Nietzsche’s analysis of such is the fact that he outright rejected it of having any merit and saw it as indicative of the decline of Western civilization. By opening his discussion by comparing the current representation of art with the way in which former advanced civilizations had embraced a degree of decadence and pessimism, Nietzsche is able to dismiss such representations without necessarily attacking the overall artistic merit that they might represent. Although from Nietzsche’s perspective, the account that he provided no doubt provided the writer a much needed salve to understand, categorize, and critique the representations of art that were integrating themselves within his time, the fact of the matter is that the approach he provided was what many might deem a bit stodgy. As has been learned, all art cannot and should not ascribe to the same measurements of form, simplicity, beauty etc. Rather, as has been noted, it is the expression of meaning, emotion, and a litany of other feelings and derivative actions that have come to make up the definition of art as it exists today. In this way, merely attacking the form due to the fact that it does not coincide with what has previously been done is closed minded in the extreme. Secondly, with respect to his claim that this particular artwork was a sign of “decline, decadence, waywardness, of wearied, enfeebled instincts” would aptly apply to the growth and/or development of any art form as it seeks to expand upon the rigid boundaries and constraints that the prior art forms have set for it. Likewise, to claim that such representations are evidence of the decline of art or the decline or civilization is of course a broad overstatement that history has proven to be both inaccurate and misleading. Such an approach is not new to the art critic; moreover, it is an approach that has been echoed by one of the most sadistic and solitarily evil regimes the world has ever seen. Due to the fact that Adolf Hitler embraced a great deal of Nietzsche’s writings and belief systems, it comes as little surprise that the Third Reich based at least some of their interpretation of modern art forms in the way that this philosopher viewed them. Due in no small part to Nietzsche’s anti-Semitism, combined with his appreciation for what he deemed as “higher” forms of art, the Third Reich expanded upon Nietzsche’s view and deemed entire genres of art as “degenerate”. As a function of this, art was repressed, artist ridiculed, imprisoned in concentration camps and some even killed. As a function of such a radical approach to the interpretation of what constituted “good” and “bad” art, the public was greeted with a narrow-minded and overly simplistic view of the purpose of art as well as what defined art and what did not. Indeed, the Nazi regime funded an exhibition that paraded a cavalcade of so called “degenerate” art around the nation; exhibiting what they deemed as uniquely wretched and sinister interpretations of art as a means to further a higher level of anti-Semitism and disgust within the populace. Naturally, what Nietzsche claimed with reference to the unique direction that art was taking during his time and how the Nazi’s twisted this interpretation to mean a uniquely anti Jewish approach are two distinctly different reactions; however, the correlation between the two should not be confused and or disregarded as one naturally lead to the extreme interpretation of the other. Such is not stated to equate Nietzsche with a type of war criminal bent on the destruction of the Jewish race; rather, it is said with the hope that the reader will take with him/her a more complete and nuanced understanding of what such a narrow minded approach to what art specifically entails. Finally, accepting such an approach does not allow the field to develop beyond the constraints that currently typify and or define it. Whereas art is the progression of ideas, technique and theme, the artist will struggle to represent himself/herself in a new way to the viewer as long as the field remains static without a degree of advancement or development. For this reason, Nietzsche’s approach is limited in that it does not allow for development beyond the former exemplifications of what he claims to be “high” art. It is interesting to note the fact that although Nietzsche himself sees the world as highly anarchical and the human ego as definitive of the truest impulses of human nature, he espouses a somewhat different approach when it comes to art. This of course could be born out of a personal preference; however it is the belief of this author that Nietzsche is instead expressing his persona tastes and using his profound powers of description and intellect to project a personal predilection rather than a categorically true statement regarding the current fate that art experienced in his (then) modern world. As a means of understanding these issues, the reader and/or researcher can attempt to ascribe a level of higher understanding to what typifies art, both within Nietzsche’s own time and within the current era. Rather than engaging art with a sense of predetermined ideals that necessarily box in the ways in which meaning and expression can be drawn, the viewer should seek to maintain a relatively open mind; albeit mindful of technique and artistic ability. Regardless of the personal tastes that one might appreciate, the fact of the matter is that art will continue to grow, will continue to expand, and will continue to leverage different means and mechanisms to express its goals to the viewer. As such, an open-minded approach is the only one in which the rational art critic should approach such issues. Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Analyze the following passage in terms of the Nietzsche's account of Essay”, n.d.)
Analyze the following passage in terms of the Nietzsche's account of Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1464984-analyze-the-following-passage-in-terms-of-the
(Analyze the Following Passage in Terms of the Nietzsche'S Account of Essay)
Analyze the Following Passage in Terms of the Nietzsche'S Account of Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1464984-analyze-the-following-passage-in-terms-of-the.
“Analyze the Following Passage in Terms of the Nietzsche'S Account of Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1464984-analyze-the-following-passage-in-terms-of-the.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Nietzsches Account of Aesthetics in the Birth of Tragedy

The Historical and Psychological Characteristics of German Modernism

The paper "The Historical and Psychological Characteristics of German Modernism" describes that the post-modernists can be seen to be following a model of historical milieus, or eras of development, similar to that posed by Nietzsche himself in 'Untimely Meditations'.... ... ... ... Goethe's microcosmic and macrocosmic projections can be seen as metaphysical literature, related to the language of dreams and prophecy as inspiration....
39 Pages (9750 words) Dissertation

Nietzsches Critique of Liberalism

The present essay is focused on the critique of liberalism expressed by Nietzsche.... As the author puts it, born in October 1844, Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche was a German philosopher, poet, composer, cultural critic as well as a classical philologist.... .... ... ... Liberalism is a political ideology that recognizes the rights of people, personal property and a free for all economy (Owen,1995)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Attic tragedy: the metaphor is the message

If scholars continue to consider the birth of tragedy a flawed, contradictory argument it is more a consequence of Nietzsche's sometimes confusing analysis than his passion for the subject of Greek Tragedy; his writing has a breathless quality to it and barrels along with the excitement of an intellectual Whodunnit.... his journey from birth to death may contain some misrepresentations and hyperbole but it never lacks a compelling story-line,fascinating us with an Apollonian/Dionysian dichotomy If scholars continue to consider the birth of tragedy a flawed, contradictory argument it is more a consequence of Nietzsche's sometimes confusing analysis than his passion for the subject of Greek Tragedy; his writing has a breathless quality to it and barrels along with the excitement of an intellectual Whodunnit....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Explain and discuss Nietzsche on truth

What the philosophers have seen in nietzsches truth are their own philosophical self-reflections though this need not be viewed as their fault but as the What is truth?... The interpreters of Nietzsche, on the other hand, tried to substantiate their philosophical biases using parts of nietzsches arguments which could be interpreted as it suited them.... While, some of these theories are in assonance with nietzsches theory of truth, some are in direct contrast with it also....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Birth of Tragedy by Nietzsche

The Apollonian is derived from Apollo, who was the Greek god of prophecy, intelligence, healing and plagues.... Conversely, Dionysus was the.... ... ... The Dionysian originated from here, as they associated the god with mystery religions precisely practised in Eleusis.... The Apollonian corresponds to the Schopenhauer which means Similarly, the Dionysian corresponds to Schopenhauer which means the principle of “will” that is highly opposed to Apollonian....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Transformation of Religious and Metaphysical Music in the Early and Middle 19th Century

The author of this research paper "Transformation of Religious and Metaphysical Music in the Early and Middle 19th Century" points out that to the middle of the 19th century, with the h appearance of the Schopenhauer's views on other hierarchy of art forms, music has gained a predominating position....
19 Pages (4750 words) Research Paper

Immanuel Kant and Friedrich Nietzsches Key Ideas

Hence there is no straightforward account of how Kant's works have influenced subsequent social thought.... This work called "Immanuel Kant and Friedrich Nietzsche's Key Ideas" focuses on two important intellectuals whose thoughts are integral to the development of social thought in Europe and North America....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Nietzsches Conception of the Dionysian and the Apollonian in The Birth of Tragedy

"Nietzsche's Conception of the Dionysian and the Apollonian in the birth of tragedy" paper gives a definition of the apollonian and the dionysian principles, examines Nietzsche's coinage of the terms the Apollonian and the Dionysian and examples of the Apollonian and Dionysian principles in nature.... Nietzsche conceived Apollonian as a form and life-giving force that makes one thing distinct and unique from all other things (Friedrich Nietzsche: the birth of tragedy, n....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us