StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Rifleman Dodd: War and the Common People, Lessons Not Learned - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the paper “Rifleman Dodd: War and the Common People, Lessons Not Learned” the author analyzes the story of one man seeking to 'do his duty or die in the attempt. It operates on too many levels for such a simplification. Two aspects stand out as universal and historical truths…
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91% of users find it useful
Rifleman Dodd: War and the Common People, Lessons Not Learned
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Rifleman Dodd: War and the Common People, Lessons Not Learned"

With regard to the 'scorched earth' policy, Dodd accepted, as a loyal, well-trained fighting man from a good regiment, much like his modern counterpart, that Wellington's orders to sweep the country clear of every living thing in order to deprive the enemy of sustenance, were necessary. Despite evidence of the effects this had on the peasants, he judged it unimportant. In persuading people to destroy what little food they had, leaving nothing but sickly herds of sheep, to starve out the enemy, the stark vision of the real-life suffering of innocents caught in the middle, is clearly depicted.

The rapes and murders are also grim reminders of the degradation of the populace in any war, before or since. They call to mind children and women, old and young, mutilated and dead, amid the straw-roofed huts in Vietnam, women raped and terrorized by the victorious Russian Army in Germany in WW2, the German atrocities in Stalingrad, the many African conflicts where women were deliberately infected with AIDs, to name a few examples; there are many more. The hardened campaigner, though saddened, may tighten his belt and get on with the job in hand, which he is programmed to do, and in Dodd's case, as part of the 'liberating' force.

This attitude is not the result of lack of intellect but perhaps suggests that it is the only way all fighting men can get through the horrors, by focusing on military or personal objective. To become too emotionally or intellectually connected to real people would prove self-destructive and counterproductive if victory is to be won. The real casualties of war are the people who have no quarrel with anyone, just trying to live their lives, destroyed in the crossfire of two superpowers, fighting for economic, political, and territorial ideologies.

  Regarding the second point, on guerilla tactics, Rifleman Dodd and his Portuguese allies provide and explanation for what is termed 'asymmetrical conflict' and demonstrate the success of such strategies. Where powerful, superior forces fight away from home, on foreign soil, where the 'foreigners' may be perceived as less than human, (despite being allies), they use their superior resources to fight huge battles, engaging in conventional warfare. Nor are they fighting for their freedom or independence, as they already possess this.

On the other hand, the lesser military power in the country of conflict will fight to the death for these, using different methods suited to their inferior resources. Thus a small group, using less conventional methods, can do much damage, just hitting, running, and hiding, wearing down the better equipped and more technologically advanced force.Forester makes the point that Dodd would do "better work for England organizing the irregulars, than back in the ranks of the 95th". This holds true with regard to Vietnam when applied to the work of the Special Forces and Marines before Westmoreland went for the big fight scene.

The lesson from Dodd and Vietnam and many another on-going conflict, which seems not to be utilized fully, is that winning people over, working with the 'resistance' or guerilla forces, would be the better tactic to employ. Such counterinsurgency initiatives have a place now, as recent events in the Middle East would suggest. Conventional warfare is no longer viable, as conflicts now are between superpowers and small countries bent on fighting to the death with whatever methods they can devise.

With that in mind, surely there is a case for examining the work of the guerillas, the resistance groups, the Marines, and all who have been able to win the hearts and minds of the people. Perhaps then, more peaceful solutions would be the outcome, there is always hope.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Rifleman Dodd: War and the Common People Book Report/Review, n.d.)
Rifleman Dodd: War and the Common People Book Report/Review. https://studentshare.org/literature/1532258-rifleman-dodd-war-and-the-common-people-summary
(Rifleman Dodd: War and the Common People Book Report/Review)
Rifleman Dodd: War and the Common People Book Report/Review. https://studentshare.org/literature/1532258-rifleman-dodd-war-and-the-common-people-summary.
“Rifleman Dodd: War and the Common People Book Report/Review”. https://studentshare.org/literature/1532258-rifleman-dodd-war-and-the-common-people-summary.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Rifleman Dodd: War and the Common People, Lessons Not Learned

Lessons Learned of the Vietnam War

The present paper aims to explore the lessons the USA has learnt from its invasion on Vietnam during mid 1950s to 1970s, as well as discovering the neglected aspects of the mistakes the US leadership should have learnt from history before making an invasion plan on some other weaker and smaller countries… The paper will also elucidate the causes and consequences of the Vietnam War in order to specify the extent of the responsibility each of the warring-parties shares in order to take the circumstances to the point of no return in such a manner that the war had eventually become inevitable in the region The Vietnam War serves as one of the most dominant and influential international conflicts appeared after the Second Great War (Mahajan, 2003) on the horizons of the world, encompassing the Far East in its fold, and leaving an indelible impact of its horrible consequences in the entire region as well as on the rest of the world at large....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Charlie Wilson's War - Lessons Learned

lessons from Charlie Wilson's War Name: Course: Lecturer: Date: The Charlie Wilson's war has countless insights helpful for national security professionals and politicians involved in messy processes and decisions culminating into world-changing events.... Therefore, the war offers great lessons concerning the inefficiencies of US foreign policy, operations of the CIA, role of women in politics and weaknesses of democratic systems of government.... Consequently, influential American women influence their wealthy friends to support generously any kind of adventure this is common, and does not only apply in Afghanistan (Michael, 2003)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Corporate Lessons Learned From Play with Kindergarteners

In the following paper “Corporate Lessons learned From Play with Kindergarteners,” the author discusses the power of play.... It is something that frees the body and mind from humdrum routines we go through every day and lets us escape to a world we fancy.... hellip; The author states that it is the play where creativity thrives and takes over to show us new perspectives....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Lessons Learned Book Review on Colin Powell

During that time he faced 28 political and military crises, like the invasion of Panama in 1989 and Operation Desert Storm in the 1991 Persian Gulf war and earned the nickname, "the reluctant warrior".... The questions that Powell Doctrine centers on are the issues of national security based on a clear and attainable objective fully analyzing the risks and costs, the full utilization of all non-violent policies, a plausible exit strategy to avoid endless entanglement, the consequences of American government action, support received from the American people on any particular action, and the presence of international support....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Military lessons learned

Tactical planners focus on the now or the present Military Lessons learned Military Lessons learned Nurses are very important in the society as they help other health professionals in providing the best medical and health care to patients.... Some lessons that can be learned from Vietnam War are related to the actions done by United States.... The leadership and the three job positions mentioned in the military group can be applied in learning the lessons from Vietnam War....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Lessons of the Cold War

hellip; The author of the paper states that the United States may effectively use the lessons learned from the cold car especially on dealing various radical Islamic movements in the same way the communist movement was dealt with in the past.... The United States may effectively use the lessons learned from the cold car especially on dealing various radical Islamic movements in the same way the communist movement was dealt with in the past (Carafano, Cox, and Rosenzweig 267)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Lessons Learned from Project Management Course

It has made me into an individual which I… I am of the opinion that project management has brought a sense of ease within my professional domains as I have learned to prioritize things on my own (Cakar 2003).... It has asked of me to manage things which were Lessons learned Project management has helped me shape up the good notions related with managing things on my own.... I am of the opinion that project management has brought a sense of ease within my professional domains as I have learned to prioritize things on my own (Cakar 2003)....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Lesson Analysis: Language Learner Investigation

The author of the paper "Lesson Analysis: Language Learner Investigation" states that students from various backgrounds require specialized approaches to teaching, imparting skills, and acquisition of knowledge depending on the subject being taught(Tomlinson, 2009).... hellip; I selected to teach a lesson in Grammar, Punctuation, and Vocabulary, having considered that learning and teaching of grammar have potential difficulties for both the students and instructor in equal measure....
7 Pages (1750 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us