StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

An analysis of Joseph Crespinos In Search of Another Country - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
We have all heard the saying, “Those who forget the past are doomed to repeat it.” This truism is one of the most important reasons to study history; an ignorance of history can be a dangerous thing. Perhaps even more dangerous is having a simplistic view of history…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.5% of users find it useful
An analysis of Joseph Crespinos In Search of Another Country
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "An analysis of Joseph Crespinos In Search of Another Country"

Your Your Repeating the Past: An Analysis of Joseph Crespino’s In Search of Another Country We have all heard the saying, “Those who forget the past are doomed to repeat it.” This truism is one of the most important reasons to study history; an ignorance of history can be a dangerous thing. Perhaps even more dangerous is having a simplistic view of history. Joseph Crespino, in his important book about the civil rights movement and the South’s response to it, In Search of Another County: Mississippi and the Conservative Counterrevolution, seeks to present a more complex view of history. Crespin, like all good history teachers, wants his readers have a fuller, more developed understanding so that they are not doomed to make incorrect interpretations and make similar mistakes of those who have gone before. According to Crespino, a simplistic view of the civil rights movement of the 1960s is that it could be put in, as reviewer Charles Payne put it, “triumphalist terms” (qutd. in Crespino 368). Payne feels that In Search of Another Country is the best retort to those who still see the civil rights movement that way. This simplistic view of civil rights sees the South, and especially the state of Mississippi, as an “icon of Southern intransigence, the key setting for what has become the modern American melodrama in which the nation finally dealt with anomalous Deep South racists and made good on its promise of equality for all its citizens” (Crespino 4). This view of history, Crespino maintains, reduces the story of the struggle for civil rights into a morality tale, ignores the ongoing struggle for racial justice, and oversimplifies the reactions of whites to civil rights both inside and outside of the South. Most importantly to Crespino is how this viewpoint of history obscures the connection of white and white conservative responses to civil rights and to their participation in the conservative counterrevolution of the Reagan era and the closing decades of the twentieth century. Of course, the reason for this simplistic viewpoint of the civil rights movement is that many of the most outrageous and virulent reactions to civil rights occurred in Mississippi. Crespino recounts several of these incidences, but recognizes that not all Mississippians were as racist as these individuals. Crespino examines Mississippi as a center of the modern conservative movement because it was atypical of the South. This period marked the creation of a powerful metaphor about Mississippi, by author James Silver in 1964—“the closed society.” By the end of the 1960s, however, racism in Mississippi became “a metaphor for all that was wrong in the nation” (Crespino 6). Perhaps the violent reaction against civil rights in Mississippi was preferable to “the quiet hypocrisy of the rest of America” (Crespino 5). Crespino’s major point in his book, while not discounting the horrible racism in Mississippi, is that racism in America was not limited to one state or even to one region of the country. Another simplistic interpretation of history is the belief of many that the modern conservative movement is connected to white supremacy in Mississippi. According to this view, modern conservatives co-opted the language of Southern white supremacy and “re-packaged” the message to appeal to the white Southern voter. Phrases like “states-rights” are codes that have sinister, racist underpinnings. Crespino presents the logic behind this viewpoint, and begins his book by making a connection between the 1964 grisly murders of three civil rights workers in Neshobo County, Mississippi and Ronald Reagan’s announcement that he was running for president just sixteen years later, at the Neshobo County Fair in 1980. This explains why many liberals insist that today, in the age of Obama, that disagreeing with our current president’s policies is tantamount to racism. At times, in Crespino’s book, it is difficult to figure out his position. In an opinion piece he wrote for Politico (2010), well after the publication of In Search of Another Country, Crespino makes the connection between civil rights opponents’ use of states’ rights to alleviate the effects of civil rights legislation with the use of the same justification to fight health care reform. To be fair, however, Crespino uses the connection to demonstrate that the opponents of Obamacare are fighting a losing battle, just as the opponents of civil rights legislation did in the 1960s. The use of fighting policies with the states’ rights argument, and how it was done to try and combat civil rights, makes it possible to understand why so many people bristle at the mere mention of states’ rights, even though as Crespino states in Politico, it was used for other issues as well. Crespino rejects the connection between white supremacy and modern conservatism, in spite of Reagan’s appearance at the Neshobo County Fair in 1980. Crespino’s logic for rejecting the connection seems to be rooted in two facts: the big change in the voting demographics of Mississippi and the increase of black representation in the Mississippi legislature. Mississippi changed from a mostly rural, farm-based economy that supported white supremacy to a more business-centered economy that was not as dependent upon the status quo. Voters in Mississippi, the South, and throughout the country became alarmed at the effects of liberalism, and conservatives simply used old concepts and language centering on states’ rights and individual freedom to attract them to their ideologies. The issues voters became interested in changed—the effect of liberalism on society, fear of Communism, and the desire to educate their children, but the language used to support them did not. One of the most dangerous things about holding a simplistic view of history is that it simplifies the complexity of both Southern society and racism in America. It places the responsibility for racism on a few stereotyped Mississippian, and not where it belongs—throughout our entire society. Crespino recognizes that both Mississippi and racism is more complicated than that. He would probably disagree with President Obama’s dismissal of his political opponents—that they are angry, religious gun owners. The danger in this kind of view is that it does not address the core causes of racism. As a result, addressing racism and combating it is impossible. It also addresses the danger in obscuring the issues that conservatives are concerned about. It is certain that many conservatives understand the connection between the South’s resistance to civil rights and the way their issues are supported. Crespino understands this, and is able to see why using these old arguments will ultimately work against the conservatives who insist upon using them. At the same time, however, Crespino insists that the modern conservative movement has roots in Southern politics. If conservatives fail to understand this, they run into the danger of discounting equality in this country’s political life and of oversimplifying its historical place in the civil rights movement. Crespino sees white Mississippi and by extension, white Southern society as a whole, as more complex than the typical assessment of this period of American history. He finds this necessary because by presenting a more complicated explanation, he presents a fuller picture of the latter half of the twentieth century. He is also able to present a fuller, more complex picture of the conservative counterrevolution. There are strong implications to our country’s current political life. Crespino may even maintain that it is this attempt to over-simplify history that is at the root of the divisiveness that is a powerful aspect of the current American political scene. By doing so, we are certain to be doomed to repeat the past—to make American society as closed as Southern society was prior to the civil rights movement. In the meantime, it discourages people from coming together to work on important issues, and to ensure the freedom of all our citizens. Works Cited Crespino, Joseph. In Search of Another Country: Mississippi and the Conservative Counterrevolution. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 2007. Print. ---. “Lessons on States Rights.” Politico. 25 March 2010. Web. 12 April 12, 2011. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“An analysis of Joseph Crespinos In Search of Another Country Book Report/Review”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1415780-an-analysis-of-joseph-crespinos-in-search-of-another-country
(An Analysis of Joseph Crespinos In Search of Another Country Book Report/Review)
https://studentshare.org/history/1415780-an-analysis-of-joseph-crespinos-in-search-of-another-country.
“An Analysis of Joseph Crespinos In Search of Another Country Book Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1415780-an-analysis-of-joseph-crespinos-in-search-of-another-country.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF An analysis of Joseph Crespinos In Search of Another Country

Joseph Stalin Politics

An author of this writing attempts to describe a brief biography of joseph Stalin.... hellip; joseph Vissarionovich Stalin was a soviet politician and Bolshevik revolutionary.... Moreover, the writer pays special attention to the political activity of Stalin....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Brother, Im Dying by Edwidge Danticat

hellip; In the story "Brother, I'm Dying ", Uncle joseph, a pastor, suffers a bout of throat cancer that seems to eat into his identity.... This discussion has to establish whether the onslaught of the Bel Air gangs managed to emasculate Uncle joseph's identity.... The researcher states that despite the setbacks that are orchestrated against Uncle joseph, by the Bel Air gangs, the US Customs, and the Department of Homeland Security even to the point of his death, Uncle joseph did not forfeit his identity....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Stephen Joseph Theatre: The Search for Funds

One of the venues where people can satiate their desire to experience the arts is the Stephen joseph Theatre.... The Stephen joseph Theatre is basically a theatre in the round in Scarborough and was actually the first of its kind in Britain.... The theatre takes its name from its founder, Stephen joseph....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Joseph Story in Bible and Quran

The same is particularly the case with Joseph's Biblical and Quran account that the readers could easily judge that the story maintains one and the same source of inspiration, depicting the holy life of joseph, his spiritual status and position, his brother's nefarious plan against him, his journey to Egypt as a slave, years in imprisonment and finally rising as the King of Egypt in later years.... The jealousy of joseph's half brothers was actually an outcome of the former's dream, in which he had found the sun, the moon and eleven stars prostrating before him (Genesis 37: 5-9; Qur'an, 12:4)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Market research in another country

Since 2011 the country's unemployment has dropped by almost a full percent from 6.... ov) There has been a huge increase in the growth of the country to include individuals building new houses or remodeling them, however times are still tough so the need for a quality item at a more reasonable price is needed to ensure the success of our product in Canada.... Demography: analysis and synthesis : a treatise in population studies....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The American Chamber of Commerce

Just as with any of such networks, the American chamber of commerce has pioneered the development of business both country Analysis The chamber of commerce refers to a type of business network whose main objective is to sustain the interests of both the business and the investors.... Just as with any of such networks, the American chamber of commerce has pioneered the development of business both in the country and in the international society including France (Kotler & Kevin, 2010)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

South Sudan in the United Nations

South Sudan gained… tical independence from its mother country of Sudan in July 9, 2011 after a referendum made early in January 2011 showed majority of the people wanted to secede from Sudan after decades of civil war resulting from systematic discrimination, neglect, and outright exploitation.... It is a landlocked country in north-eastern Africa with most of the people belonging to the different tribes but many of them are not Muslims unlike that of Sudan itself....
5 Pages (1250 words) Outline

Joseph Smith and Ralph Waldo Emerson

The purpose of the paper "Joseph Smith and Ralph Waldo Emerson" is to explain the role of joseph Smith and Ralph Waldo in the 19th century and what were the major contributions of both these men to the world and how they managed to escort their ideas and plans?... The corruption in the Bible and practices of Christianity were the main arguments of joseph and he declared the proper Christianity practices into the world.... he purpose of this paper is to explain the role of joseph Smith and Ralph Waldo in the 19th century....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us