StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

A Critique on the Kyoto Protocols - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay discusses a critique of the Kyoto Protocols. The world has experienced drastic changes in climatic conditions due to irresponsible handling of natural resources. The product of industrialization, growth, technological development all account to rises in greenhouse gases…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.3% of users find it useful
A Critique on the Kyoto Protocols
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "A Critique on the Kyoto Protocols"

A Critique on the Kyoto Protocols Introduction The world has experienced drastic changes in climatic conditions due to irresponsible handling of natural resources. The product of industrialization, growth, technological development and urbanization all account to rises in greenhouse gases. According to Kim, et.al. (2010), greenhouse gases include carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), water vapor, and fluorinated gases which all act as a “greenhouse around the earth.  This means that they let the heat from the Sun into the atmosphere, but do not allow the heat to escape back into space.  The more greenhouse gases there are, the larger the percentage of heat that is trapped inside the earth’s atmosphere” (Kim, et.al, 2010, par. 2). In the discourse, global warming was specifically defined as “climate change that causes an increase in the average temperature of the lower atmosphere.  Global warming can have many different causes, but it is most commonly associated with human interference, specifically the release of excessive amounts of greenhouse gases” (ibid.). With the alarming levels of greenhouse gases continuing to increase at unprecedented pace, scientists all over the world drastically made efforts to inform the international organizations in charge of environmental protection. An international treaty, the United Nations Framework Convention of Climate Change (UNFCCC) deemed it of primary importance to address global warming issues through its governance and with the assistance of another international agreement, the Kyoto Protocol. According to the official website of UNFCCC, the Kyoto Protocol “sets binding targets for 37 industrialized countries and the European community for reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions .These amount to an average of five per cent against 1990 levels over the five-year period 2008-2012” (UNFCCC, 2010, par. 1). In this regard, the essay aims to proffer one’s personal opinion as to what world leaders and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) should agree on. Likewise, the essay seeks to address the following concerns, to wit: (1) is there a solution that they should commit to? If so, what is it? If not, then what should they do? (2) Why haven't the Kyoto Protocols worked? What has not worked and why? What has worked and why? (3) What should be the role of the US? And (4) what should be the role of China?  Personal Opinion. Diverse articles and publications on UNFCCC and Kyoto Protocol reveal that their primary thrust is “to stabilize greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere at a level that will prevent dangerous human interference with the climate system. They are designed to assist countries in adapting to the inevitable effects of climate change. They facilitate the development of techniques that can help increase resilience to climate change impacts – for example, the development of salt-resistant crops – and to exchange best practices with regard to adaptation” (UNFCCC: Fact Sheet, n.d., pars. 3 & 6). The relevant distinction between the two organizations is that “while the Convention encouraged industrialized countries to stabilize greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, the Protocol commits them to do so” (UNFCC, 2010, par. 2) The word encourage as an aim of UNFCCC (the Convention) is weak in view of the eminent danger posed by global warming. It is no wonder that since its inception in 1994 it failed to elicit the response required of its member parties. On the other hand, the objective of the Kyoto Protocol is to commit member parties to stabilize GHG emissions through three market based mechanisms of emissions trading, clean development mechanisms (CDM), and joint implementation. Despite the enumerated mechanisms, eligibility requirements, reporting and compliance monitoring, it is hard to believe that since its adoption in 1997, already 13 years ago, until now there is no concrete and substantial improvement in the reduction and stabilization of GHG emissions. It is a personal conviction that the dilemma lies in the objectives and standards set by both international endeavors. Since both have acknowledged that there is indeed an impending threat to the environment posed by global warming, they should have identified specific goals and targets in terms of scheduling which aspect of climate change should be addressed in hierarchical order. The scope of climate change and global warming is so vast that member countries could simply report that all aspects are concurrently addressed without specifically focusing on areas that need to be prioritized to have a significant effect to reduce GHG emissions. In fact, in a published online report from Spiegel International, it reported that the United Nation’s Climate Chief, Yvo de Boer, announced his resignation in view of “the intractable problem of bringing the UN's 192 member governments to some kind of binding resolution” (Moore, 2010, par. 2). His desperate efforts to unite party members realized that governments could not possibly resolve issues given their expertise venturing on policy frameworks rather than on concrete solutions to impending problems. Boer acknowledged that solutions should come from businesses. In this regard, the IPCC and Kyoto Protocol should re evaluate their stance and recognize the need to identify and prioritize the specific aspects in stabilizing GHG emissions. Under their provisions for measures that can be done: (reducing emissions, expanding forests, changing lifestyles and rules, and coping) – specific areas must be prioritized and member countries must all focus on the identified area at given time frames. For instance, for the years 2010 – 2012, the focus is on reducing emissions. All member parties must exert all efforts in working towards this objective. Scientists the world over could advise and recommend ways to reduce emissions at all cost in all countries - not just on member parties. Then, reporting, which is required to be done annually, must be revised to a more shorted period, say every six months to solicit feedback and to address any improvements, as required. Therefore, at this point in time, both IPCC and Kyoto Protocol could not commit any solution because the environmental problem they have laid on member governments are so vast and enormous in span and extent that addressing them all at the same time would be chaotic and simply unviable. As suggested, through prioritization of objectives with strict time frames, coupled with regular reporting and monitoring standards, tasks would be simpler, more structured and systematized. As noted, the Kyoto Protocol failed to achieve its objective of commiting member parties to stabilize GHG emissions despite clearly and explicitly stated market based mechanisms due to the shotgun approach. It expects member parties to implement all suggested mechanisms at the same time. Although there have been achievements to date, these were very minimal and reported recurrence of rising emissions despite previous successful efforts of reduction. The report from UNFCCC indicated that “between 1990 and 2000, the total greenhouse-gas emissions of industrialized countries actually declined slightly (by 5.6 per cent) -- but that reflected unusual circumstances… now the Eastern European "economies in transition" are growing again, and their emissions are rising. The real work, what is really needed -- worldwide economic progress combined with reduced emissions -- has yet to be accomplished” (UNFCCC: Accomplishments, n.d., par. 1) In addition, there have been reports indicating that the credibility and authenticity of the research published by the IPCC were questionable and doubtful. In one article published by Guardian News and Media Limited, Juliette Jowit reported that the “Dutch government finds minor inaccuracies in contested paper, but reasserts that 'climate change poses "substantial risks" to most parts of the world” (Jowit, 2010, par. 1). She further averred that “the Dutch panel of experts claims it found 12 errors - from a criticism of the number of people in Africa at risk of water shortages to mistakes in references or typing. It also suggested the summary version of the report had portrayed an over-dramatic picture by putting the emphasis on negative impacts of climate change, and it failed to explain some of the threats were not only driven by climate change” (Jowit, 2010, par. 3). It was therefore recommended that more efforts must be made to review the sources of information before reports are to be published. In addition, the initial contention of the United States not to support the Kyoto Protocol contributed to its failure. Since the United States “releases more greenhouse gases than any other nation and accounts for more than 25 percent of those generated by humans worldwide” (West, 2010, par. 5), it plays a major role in supporting the objectives of the Kyoto Protocol and playing an active part in ensuring that a more feasible implementation program must be adhered to. As indicated by West, one of the provisions noted by the US was consisted with the recommendation provided above, to wit: “prior to negotiation of the Kyoto Protocol, the U.S. Senate passed a resolution saying the U.S. should not sign any protocol that failed to include binding targets and timetables for both developing and industrialized nations” (West, 2010, par. 10). The article written by Palieschesky (2010) revealed that “some countries are exempt from the Kyoto Protocol because they have historically been less responsible for the generation of greenhouse gases. China and India are two of the nations exempt from the protocol” (par. 2). However, facts and details about global warming in China revealed that “China is the largest producer of greenhouse gases and the largest emitter of carbon dioxide. It was not supposed to overtake the United States as the world’s leading producer of greenhouse gases until 2020 but a study by a Dutch government-funded group released in June 2007 determined that China was already the world’s No. 1 emitter of carbon dioxide then” (Hays, 2008, par. 1). In this regard, China should also support the aim of the Kyoto Protocol. Conclusion The success of the Kyoto Protocol and the efforts of the IPCC would be determined not only by the participation of developing member nations, as initially stated. Global warming, as the term suggests, is a global concern. All people for all walks of life, regardless of nationality and culture will be affected by its dangerous threats. For the Kyoto Protocol to report a significant accomplishment in the next scheduled meeting, a more structured prioritized climatic measure to stabilize GHG emission should be identified and focused on at a clearly defined time frame – with the participation of all nations all over the world. Works Cited Hays, Jeffrey. Global Warming in China. 2008. Web. 21 August 2010. < http://factsanddetails.com/china.php?itemid=393&catid=10&subcatid=66#> Jowit, Juliette. “Review of questioned IPCC report says conclusions 'well-founded'.” Guardian.co.uk. 5 July 2010. Web. 21 August 2010. < http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2010/jul/05/dutch-support-ipcc> Kim, YeSeul, Granger, Erika, Puckett, Katie, Hasar, Cankutan, & Francel, Leif. Global Warming: Definition. 2010. Web. 21 August 2010. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A Critique on the Kyoto Protocols Research Paper”, n.d.)
A Critique on the Kyoto Protocols Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1741216-kyoto-protocols-as-well-as-the-ipcc-and-the-upcoming-climate-change-summits
(A Critique on the Kyoto Protocols Research Paper)
A Critique on the Kyoto Protocols Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1741216-kyoto-protocols-as-well-as-the-ipcc-and-the-upcoming-climate-change-summits.
“A Critique on the Kyoto Protocols Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1741216-kyoto-protocols-as-well-as-the-ipcc-and-the-upcoming-climate-change-summits.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Critique on the Kyoto Protocols

Simulation Based Routing Protocols Analysis

Comparing the two routing protocols regarding end to end delay, throughput and delay jitter, the end to end delay of EIGRP and OSPF is from 65ms to 185 ms with a 15% network load.... Simulation Based Routing protocols Analysis.... Routing protocol particularize how data packets between computers is forwarded through circulating information between different nodes on a telecommunications network....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Surgery clinical guidelines and protocols

There is a clear distinction between clinical guidelines and protocols.... Clinical protocols, on the other hand, give specific details about the treatment and procedure that should be employed by the surgical team (PCEL 2007, p.... Difference between clinical guidelines and protocols and their importance within surgery Difference between clinical guidelinesand protocols and their importance within surgery There is a clear distinction between clinical guidelines and protocols....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The future of RFID protocols

Improved computing capacities should allow RFID protocols to employ only pseudo-arbitrary validation messages for tags complying… 842).... In addition, RFID protocols should entail new arbitrary figures as one of the inputs of MAC function to reduce the likelihood of initiating an effective Running Head: THE FUTURE OF RFID protocols The Future of RFID protocols By StateDate The Future of RFID protocols The future of RFID protocols should revolve around computing capacities, necessity, identification, matching, verification, and performance factors....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Cracking time for different protocols

Different security protocols have different types and numbers of weak points that hackers need for infiltration or intrusion.... Difference in protocols is evident in their design (Miltchev et al.... For… Another example is widely used security protocols that do not normally entail the provisions for dependable authentication as part of the central protocol.... SMTP, Running Head: CRACKING TIME FOR DIFFERENT protocols CRACKING TIME FOR DIFFERENT protocols By University nameCity, StateDate Cracking Time for Different protocols Different protocols affect the hacking time required to break....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

What Have Kyoto Protocols and European Emission Trading Scheme Achieved on Sustainable Development

The paper "What Have kyoto protocols and European Emission Trading Scheme Achieved on Sustainable Development?... tells the inability of these agreements to come up with obligatory emission goals on developing countries such as China was a basic error in kyoto and it should be corrected in future....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

International Environmental Agreements

They are the kyoto Protocol, the Ozone Annex, and the Montreal Protocol.... continued its membership to the UNFCCC but avoided any involvement with the kyoto Protocol.... had embraced some of the kyoto Protocol's regulations.... the kyoto Protocol is viewed as an essential initiative towards a genuine reduction of greenhouse gas emission worldwide.... Currently, in Durban, adjustment plans are underway to develop new protocols agreeable to all parties, whose implementation is anticipated by the year 2020....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Kyoto Protocol in the Context of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change

The most pivotal aspect of the kyoto Protocol is that it stipulates targets for minimizing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, to 37 countries that are industrialized.... (1) the kyoto Protocol came into effect in the year 2005.... As a matter of fact, the Protocol is also having a system of compliance making sure that all the parties are indeed adhering to the stipulations of the kyoto Protocol.... (1) China and India have also signed the kyoto Protocol, but these regions are not bound to initiate measures for bringing down the GHG emission levels....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Kyoto Protocols Potency

The paper "Advantages and Disadvantages of the kyoto Protocol" is a great example of an essay on environmental studies.... trengths of the kyoto protocolThis mechanism helps to motivate green investment and help parties meet their release target in a cost-effective way.... mong the kyoto protocol's potency is its addition of a provision for a market-based approach intended to lower the cost of the worldwide climate system: discharge trading amongst the countries that take target under the protocol; joining the completion which allows for project-live trade among the nations; and clean progress mechanism, which offers for the use of project-level release offsets created in non-developing nations to help gather for the compliance duty of firm in developing countries (UNFCCC, 1997)....
3 Pages (750 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us