StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Menken's Dead Gods - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
Yes, I absolutely agree with Menken that these are now dead gods. I consider these gods as dead because, as Menken pointed out, nobody worship or even remember them (Mencken 1)…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.4% of users find it useful
Menkens Dead Gods
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Menken's Dead Gods"

?Do you agree with Menken that these are now dead gods? Yes, I absolutely agree with Menken that these are now dead gods. I consider these gods as dead because, as Menken pointed out, nobody worship or even remember them (Mencken 1). Just as the memory of a dead man is lost and forgotten except among his lovers, so also the memory of these gods is lost and forgotten. Take for instance, Huitzilopochtli, who was the national god of the Aztec of Tenochtitlan and the most celebrated and feared of all the gods of the ancient Aztec (Andrews 223). The Aztec built a great temple on the Pyramid in Tenochtitlan in his honor. At its completion ceremonies, it is reported that more than 20,000 human sacrifices were offered in a four day celebration (Andrews 224). This attests to position Huitzilopochtli occupied among the ancient Aztec. However, apart from a few savage in the Mexican forest, Huitzilopochtli is as dead as dead great men like General Coxey Richmond P. Hobson because he lives only in history (Mencken 1). No one worship or pay reverence to him in any form. He is a forgotten character even among the present day Aztec. Huitzilopochtli is not the only god that is a victim of death. Indeed, the numerous Roman gods and goddesses such as Jupiter and Venus (Platner and Ashby 25), the Egyptian gods and goddesses such as Isis and Osiris (British Broadcasting Corporation), have undergone similar fate. Jupiter is no longer worshiped by present day Romans nor is Osiris of any relevance to the 21st century Egyptian. The same applies to all the gods mentioned by Mencken. These gods live only in history like great man like Abraham Lincoln. Their temples and place of worship are historical monuments just like the home of Abraham Lincoln is a history monument. Thus I absolutely concur with Menken that these are now dead gods. What would a dead god be? From human perspective, to be dead means to be lifeless. Related to this is the fact that a dead person’s inability to procreate. In addition, a dead person does not response to external stimuli neither can he influence events. The dead person lives only in history and in the memory of those that love him. Thus a dead god would be lifeless, powerless, lacking influence and the ability to response to stress and procreate and following these characteristics, he lacks worshippers. In fact, the ability to procreate and response to external influences are the determining characteristics of the living. Indeed, the gods mentioned by Mencken exhibits these traits. Huitzilopochtli, for instance, cannot response if he is insulted or when his temple is abused. He cannot influence events happening around him. A dead god has no influence on present day events. He has lost its place. Like the dead man, he lives only in the mind of his lovers and in history. He does not create anything neither does he initiate ideas. Nobody attributes great inventions and ideas to the gods mentioned by Mencken, at least in our time. A living god is a source of inspiration to its followers. A dead god provides no inspiration. As a result of all the lacks of the dead god as mentioned above, he has no worshippers or followers. Indeed, the trademark of a dead god is his lack of followers and worshipper (Mencken 1). This follows from the dead god inability to influence events and to response to external events. Why are other gods still alive? To be alive means to respond to changes in the environment, to influences events, to initiate ideas, and to procreate. These are characteristics of the living. Gods are acclaimed to be alive if they are held responsible for events happening in the society. As a result, they attract followers, who flock to their temples to worship. Indeed, other gods are alive because they are still considered to be accountable for events happening in the society. At least their followers held them accountable! This attracts thousands, if not millions, of followers to their place of worship. Take for instance Jesus Christ, who the Christian believed to be God. To the Christians, he shaped their personal life and also history of humanity. As a result, he is considered to be alive. Following his influence on the events in the society, the Christian god has worshippers. Indeed, he is worshipped by millions. Thus a god is considered alive if he is considered to have influence in events in the society and therefore has followers who worship him (Mencken 1). If one says their god is real because they believe in that god, isn’t this just a version of Peter Pan’s request that we clap if we believe in fairies? (Can belief make anything real?) Certainly, belief cannot make anything real. For instance, a child or a mental patient has many beliefs, most of which are not real. For instance, a mental patient may believe that he is the president of the United States but that is not real. Likewise, in a child’s world, his parents are the most powerful people on earth but that is far from the reality. This suggests that belief in a god does not make them real. First, we define reality (to be real). Reality is the states of things as they actually exist and not as they may appear in the mind or how we feel about them (Kockelmans 311). Given this definition, our beliefs, definitely, does not create or alter reality. Most often, the gods are creation of the human imagination. They exist only in the human mind. In reality, they are nothing except what the believer thinks in his subjective mind. One may argue that if a person believes in a god, that god becomes real at least to that person. That is far from the truth. The analogy of the mental patient that believes and thinks he is the president of the United States or the child who believes that his/her parents are the strongest of all parents comes to mind. No matter how strong the patient or child belief, reality cannot be altered. The mental patient is not the president nor is the child’s parents the strongest. Thus for one to say that his/her god is real because he/she believes in that god, is, indeed, another version of Peter Pan’s request that we clap if we believe in fairies? Belief cannot make anything real. Reference Andrews, J. R. Introduction to Classical Nahuatl (revised ed.). Norman University of Oklahoma Press, 2003. Print British Broadcasting Corporation. “Ancient Egyptian Gods Gallery.” http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/ancient/egyptians/gods_gallery.shtml 29/03/2011. Retrieved on 3 May 2011. Online Kockelmans, J. Edmund Husserl's phenomenology (2nd ed.). Purdue: Purdue University Press, 2001. Print Mencken, H. L. “Where is the graveyard of dead gods.” http://www.graveyardofthegods.org/deadgods/graveyard.html. 2011. Retrieved on 3 May 2011. Online Platner, S. B., & Ashby, T. A topographical dictionary of ancient Rome. London: Oxford University Press, 1929. Print Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Menken's Dead Gods Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1419849-menkens-dead-gods
(Menken'S Dead Gods Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1419849-menkens-dead-gods.
“Menken'S Dead Gods Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1419849-menkens-dead-gods.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Menken's Dead Gods

William Jennings Byrant's Defense of the Bible in John Scopes Trial and Henry Louis Menken's View

(1998), When All the gods Trembled: Darwinism, Scopes, and American Intellectuals, pp.... … William Jennings Byrant's defense of the Bible in John Scopes Trial and Henry Louis menken's view on the dangers of fundamentalism: Why do you think William Jennings Bryant agreed to testify?... William Jennings Byrant's defense of the Bible in John Scopes Trial and Henry Louis menken's view on the dangers of fundamentalism: Why do you thinkWilliam Jennings Bryant agreed to testify?...
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Contribution to Medicine by Mendel

… When these new genes are arranged in the chromosomes, there is possibility that they arrange in an order where two genes with opposing properties (like tall and short) may come to stay near each other, and these are known as alleles.... It is being increasingly recognized that all human characters including diseases are determined by genes, and chromosomes are not identical, and they have specific locations for individual genes....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Business Environment in China

China had been protective in opening its trading and distribution services sector.... Prior to December 11th, 2004, when the 3-year transition period lapsed, foreign investors wanting their own distribution vehicles in China had to resort to trading companies established in free trade zones, minority-owned joint ventures, or China investment holding companies (for some 250 investors who are big enough to afford them)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

The Natural Step Business Model

Sustainability is a method of harvesting or using resources so that the resources do not exhaust and or permanently get damaged.... It also involves a lifestyle involving the use of sustainable methods.... It has taken many forms in variant aspects.... Sustainability also means living within the limits and understanding the interconnections amongst society, economy and environment....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Sasha Jensen's Interior Landscape

The first few lines of 'Good Morning, Midnight' take the reader immediately into Sasha's mind, with her inner dialog, her stream-of-consciousness flowing effortlessly back, forth, and bubbling in the present.... The apparent preoccupation with drinking, alcohol, crying and seeking places to hide, which lead to vivid descriptions of lavatories and the feelings they elicit, may cause us to assume we will experience the disintegration of an aging, alcoholic, suicidal woman....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

An Overview of Italian Textile Industry

Following a period of rapid growth in the '90s, during which major Italian fashion companies acquired new brands and boutiques like they were going out of style, the current business climate is strictly focused on cost control and improving internal efficiency.... hellip; (CSC, 2006) The problems facing the Italian textile industry are due to the competition posed by China....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Pros and Cons of Death Penalty: When Death is Not Enough

Two authors explored the pros and cons of death penalty.... In “The Penalty of Death,” H.... .... Mencken counters two common arguments against death penalty.... First,… ath penalty is degrading to those who perform and witness it; second, death penalty has no value because it does not effectively deter crime (Mencken 1)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Emmanuel Prophecy

Since time immemorial, there have been endless heated arguments and debates, both secular and Spiritual pertaining fulfilment of different prophesies.... Different people have different ideologies, perceptions, conclusions and opinions with regards to different scriptures in the… To this effect, much secular and spiritual articles and books have been written and published from as early as the 1800's....
15 Pages (3750 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us